1 00:00:08,975 --> 00:00:11,544 [somber music playing] 2 00:00:52,819 --> 00:00:54,421 [music fades] 3 00:01:01,294 --> 00:01:03,530 Okay. You ready? 4 00:01:16,543 --> 00:01:18,144 - It's beautiful. - [both chuckle] 5 00:01:18,278 --> 00:01:20,347 - Where'd you find this? - [chuckles] It's cute, right? 6 00:01:20,480 --> 00:01:23,350 [chuckles] Aw, I love this! 7 00:01:23,483 --> 00:01:24,818 - So cute. - [both chuckle] 8 00:01:26,486 --> 00:01:28,188 It's perfect! [chuckles] 9 00:01:32,258 --> 00:01:34,394 [chuckles softly] 10 00:01:34,527 --> 00:01:37,130 It would've been, you know, a lot for me. 11 00:01:37,263 --> 00:01:39,990 - Thank you. - Yeah. 12 00:01:41,401 --> 00:01:42,402 It's perfect. 13 00:01:43,269 --> 00:01:44,237 You're perfect. 14 00:01:46,706 --> 00:01:48,742 [laughter nearby] 15 00:01:48,875 --> 00:01:50,677 Are they here already? 16 00:01:50,810 --> 00:01:52,212 They're like 30 minutes early. 17 00:01:52,345 --> 00:01:53,813 - Why are they-- What? - Hey. 18 00:01:53,947 --> 00:01:54,748 It's okay. 19 00:01:59,152 --> 00:02:00,820 - [chuckles] - I love it. 20 00:02:01,454 --> 00:02:02,722 Yeah? 21 00:02:02,856 --> 00:02:04,424 I'll be honest. Ally and I, you know, 22 00:02:04,557 --> 00:02:06,893 we weren't sure about whether to have this party, 23 00:02:07,270 --> 00:02:09,396 but together there's nothing we can't overcome. 24 00:02:09,529 --> 00:02:11,970 You're the strongest woman I know. 25 00:02:11,231 --> 00:02:13,990 I love you more than anything. 26 00:02:13,233 --> 00:02:14,534 And I'm so damn excited 27 00:02:14,668 --> 00:02:16,102 to keep building our lives together. 28 00:02:16,236 --> 00:02:18,238 - Me too. I love you. - Love you. 29 00:02:18,371 --> 00:02:20,573 [all] Aw. 30 00:02:20,707 --> 00:02:22,308 Why don't you ever say anything like that about me? 31 00:02:22,442 --> 00:02:24,644 Thank you all for being here. Thank you. 32 00:02:27,847 --> 00:02:28,782 Vitamins are on the table. 33 00:02:28,915 --> 00:02:30,450 Oh. Thank you, baby. 34 00:02:32,218 --> 00:02:33,920 [sighs] 35 00:02:34,540 --> 00:02:35,755 - It was a nice party. - Yeah. 36 00:02:35,889 --> 00:02:36,856 Think everyone had a good time. 37 00:02:36,990 --> 00:02:38,725 Yeah. You deserve it. 38 00:02:40,393 --> 00:02:43,296 You're just buttering me up before you abandon me. 39 00:02:43,430 --> 00:02:45,765 I wish I could delay it again. 40 00:02:45,899 --> 00:02:47,367 - I know. - I don't want to leave you here. 41 00:02:47,500 --> 00:02:49,350 You just go to the judge 42 00:02:49,169 --> 00:02:50,904 and tell him something wildly inappropriate 43 00:02:51,370 --> 00:02:52,539 and then come back to me. 44 00:02:52,672 --> 00:02:54,307 - I will. - Oh, you will? 45 00:02:54,441 --> 00:02:55,809 - Mmm-hmm. Yeah. I got some-- - Oh, you will? Like what? 46 00:02:55,942 --> 00:02:57,577 - I'll say... [chuckles] - What? 47 00:02:57,711 --> 00:02:59,446 I'll say we're having a big old orgy tomorrow night 48 00:02:59,579 --> 00:03:00,580 and they're all invited. 49 00:03:00,714 --> 00:03:01,948 - [laughs] - Ow! 50 00:03:02,820 --> 00:03:03,249 Ooh. No, no, no. Be careful. Careful. 51 00:03:03,383 --> 00:03:04,951 All right. That got me too excited. 52 00:03:05,850 --> 00:03:06,419 [both laugh] 53 00:03:07,320 --> 00:03:08,388 All right. 54 00:03:09,889 --> 00:03:10,990 Hey. 55 00:03:11,124 --> 00:03:12,325 - Sorry. Sorry, sorry. - Hey. 56 00:03:22,350 --> 00:03:24,971 [man on radio] Just a reminder to send in those mail-in ballots soon. 57 00:03:25,105 --> 00:03:27,307 We're only two weeks out from election date, folks, 58 00:03:27,440 --> 00:03:29,109 and every ballot matters. 59 00:03:29,242 --> 00:03:30,844 So be sure to get yours in before it's too late. 60 00:03:30,977 --> 00:03:32,112 [turns off radio] 61 00:03:35,882 --> 00:03:37,250 [woman on phone] Faith, come on. 62 00:03:37,384 --> 00:03:38,952 Polling has you at a 46-point deadlock, 63 00:03:39,850 --> 00:03:41,540 with 8% of voters still undecided. 64 00:03:41,187 --> 00:03:43,156 We need to push your plan to reduce the crime rate 65 00:03:43,289 --> 00:03:44,290 in order to pull ahead. 66 00:03:44,424 --> 00:03:45,959 But this case is my campaign. 67 00:03:46,920 --> 00:03:47,293 He's a dangerous criminal 68 00:03:47,427 --> 00:03:48,862 with a long history of violence. 69 00:03:48,995 --> 00:03:50,697 I put James Sythe away, we win. 70 00:03:50,830 --> 00:03:52,165 [sighs] If you lose, you lose your shot at being DA. 71 00:03:52,298 --> 00:03:53,600 - All right. I got to go. - Faith-- 72 00:03:54,300 --> 00:03:55,535 [sighs] 73 00:04:04,444 --> 00:04:06,460 - Oh. There she is. - [cameras clicking] 74 00:04:08,481 --> 00:04:09,983 Hey. Excuse me! 75 00:04:10,116 --> 00:04:11,384 You, uh... 76 00:04:11,518 --> 00:04:12,485 You dropped this. 77 00:04:13,186 --> 00:04:14,587 Oh. I did. 78 00:04:14,721 --> 00:04:16,156 Oh, my God. Thank you. You're a lifesaver. 79 00:04:16,289 --> 00:04:17,524 - No worries. Have a good day. - [chuckles] 80 00:04:17,657 --> 00:04:18,858 Yeah. You too. 81 00:04:22,529 --> 00:04:24,464 - Through that door. - [woman] Oh, thank you. 82 00:04:26,320 --> 00:04:27,734 Where do I go for, uh, jury duty? 83 00:04:27,867 --> 00:04:28,868 Go down there. 84 00:04:31,204 --> 00:04:32,205 Thanks. 85 00:04:47,320 --> 00:04:49,723 [bailiff] All right, guys. Eyes up. 86 00:04:49,856 --> 00:04:50,924 Pay attention. 87 00:04:52,692 --> 00:04:54,527 [narrator on TV] Hello. I'd like to welcome you 88 00:04:54,661 --> 00:04:57,630 as a juror in the Georgia court system. 89 00:04:57,197 --> 00:05:00,200 As a juror, you protect the right of every person 90 00:05:00,333 --> 00:05:01,801 to a trial by jury. 91 00:05:01,935 --> 00:05:03,503 The right to a trial by jury 92 00:05:03,636 --> 00:05:06,172 is a cornerstone of our democracy. 93 00:05:06,306 --> 00:05:07,707 That right is protected 94 00:05:07,841 --> 00:05:09,709 by the United States constitution. 95 00:05:12,278 --> 00:05:13,313 - [man] There she is. - [sighs] 96 00:05:13,446 --> 00:05:14,914 Sugar-free vanilla with skim. 97 00:05:15,480 --> 00:05:16,583 [Faith] Ah. You're good. 98 00:05:16,716 --> 00:05:17,617 - Can I get you something else? - [Faith] Mmm-mmm. 99 00:05:17,751 --> 00:05:19,520 You got something for me? 100 00:05:19,185 --> 00:05:21,540 [sighs] Okay. Voluntary manslaughter 101 00:05:21,187 --> 00:05:22,722 with a recommendation of 20 years. 102 00:05:22,856 --> 00:05:24,324 Fifteen to serve, followed by five on probation. 103 00:05:24,457 --> 00:05:25,859 Wow. That's a hell of a deal. 104 00:05:25,992 --> 00:05:27,827 I will even waive the recidivist statute 105 00:05:27,961 --> 00:05:29,429 if he pleads before we strike the jury. 106 00:05:29,562 --> 00:05:31,640 And admit to something he didn't do? 107 00:05:31,197 --> 00:05:33,867 [chuckles] Save it for the jury. 108 00:05:34,000 --> 00:05:36,503 Better yet, why don't you plead your guy out 109 00:05:36,636 --> 00:05:39,500 and say, free for your caseload. 110 00:05:39,139 --> 00:05:40,140 Look... [sighs] 111 00:05:41,574 --> 00:05:43,176 my client wants a trial. 112 00:05:43,309 --> 00:05:46,446 Well, then, you're wasting my time and your client's. 113 00:05:46,579 --> 00:05:47,580 Last chance. 114 00:05:49,582 --> 00:05:50,650 After you. 115 00:05:58,391 --> 00:06:02,462 The case you're about to hear is an alleged homicide. 116 00:06:02,595 --> 00:06:05,131 The state is charging James Michael Sythe 117 00:06:05,265 --> 00:06:06,633 with malice murder 118 00:06:06,766 --> 00:06:09,803 for the death of Kendall Alice Carter. 119 00:06:09,936 --> 00:06:12,605 Now, if any of you have a personal relationship 120 00:06:12,739 --> 00:06:14,774 with the accused, and/or the deceased 121 00:06:14,908 --> 00:06:17,243 that will prohibit you from serving on this panel 122 00:06:17,377 --> 00:06:19,179 in an unbiased manner, 123 00:06:19,312 --> 00:06:20,580 please speak now. 124 00:06:28,988 --> 00:06:29,956 Yes. 125 00:06:32,580 --> 00:06:33,259 [exhales] 126 00:06:33,393 --> 00:06:34,627 He used to ride my bus. 127 00:06:36,262 --> 00:06:37,430 And when was this? 128 00:06:38,798 --> 00:06:41,568 [sighs] I don't know. Few years ago. 129 00:06:41,701 --> 00:06:45,205 Okay. Then there's no reason we can't leave it there. 130 00:06:45,338 --> 00:06:47,707 I think you'll make a fine juror. 131 00:06:47,841 --> 00:06:49,876 Does anyone else think 132 00:06:50,100 --> 00:06:53,246 that they're incapable of serving on this panel? 133 00:06:54,514 --> 00:06:55,615 Yes. 134 00:06:57,450 --> 00:06:58,952 Uh... 135 00:06:59,850 --> 00:07:00,620 Your Honor, my wife is in the third trimester 136 00:07:00,754 --> 00:07:02,389 of a high-risk pregnancy. 137 00:07:02,522 --> 00:07:04,858 I'd like to be available to her. 138 00:07:04,991 --> 00:07:06,526 Well, that's commendable. 139 00:07:06,659 --> 00:07:08,628 What hours do you normally work? 140 00:07:09,696 --> 00:07:11,631 Uh, 9:00 to 6:00, typically. 141 00:07:11,765 --> 00:07:13,400 Then you have my word that this court 142 00:07:13,533 --> 00:07:17,170 will not demand one minute more of your time than that. 143 00:07:18,872 --> 00:07:19,739 Yeah. 144 00:07:21,408 --> 00:07:23,343 See, the fact that you don't want to be here 145 00:07:23,476 --> 00:07:25,110 is exactly what makes you 146 00:07:25,145 --> 00:07:28,148 the perfect group to judicate this case. 147 00:07:29,482 --> 00:07:31,151 You are impartial. 148 00:07:31,284 --> 00:07:34,354 You have no skin in the game. Nothing to gain or lose. 149 00:07:34,487 --> 00:07:36,923 And that is why I believe that this process, 150 00:07:37,570 --> 00:07:39,859 as flawed as it may be, 151 00:07:39,993 --> 00:07:42,729 is still our best chance at finding justice. 152 00:07:45,532 --> 00:07:47,867 Do you work, Mrs. Aldworth? 153 00:07:48,100 --> 00:07:49,769 Well, I had the toughest job there is. 154 00:07:49,903 --> 00:07:51,938 I raised two kids and just sent them off to college. 155 00:07:52,720 --> 00:07:53,740 - Ah. Congratulations. - Thank you. 156 00:07:53,873 --> 00:07:56,476 And have you ever served on a jury before? 157 00:07:56,609 --> 00:07:58,945 Twice. Both were mistrials. 158 00:07:59,790 --> 00:08:00,947 Twice. Okay. Okay. 159 00:08:01,810 --> 00:08:04,918 Mr. King. Have you ever had a physical altercation 160 00:08:05,510 --> 00:08:06,920 with a significant other? 161 00:08:07,530 --> 00:08:09,689 Are you gonna ask that question to every guy in this courtroom? 162 00:08:11,591 --> 00:08:13,193 If I have to, I will. I... 163 00:08:13,326 --> 00:08:16,229 I know these questions can be very personal-- 164 00:08:16,363 --> 00:08:17,364 Nah, man. 165 00:08:18,198 --> 00:08:19,165 That ain't me. 166 00:08:22,235 --> 00:08:23,436 Thank you, sir. 167 00:08:25,572 --> 00:08:27,841 [Faith] How long have you lived in the area, Mr. Chicowski? 168 00:08:27,974 --> 00:08:29,542 About ten years. 169 00:08:29,676 --> 00:08:30,977 And you, uh... 170 00:08:31,111 --> 00:08:32,278 Oh, you run a flower shop? 171 00:08:32,412 --> 00:08:34,447 Yeah. With my wife. 172 00:08:34,581 --> 00:08:36,549 Mr. Robinson, it says here your wife has 173 00:08:36,683 --> 00:08:38,918 primary custody of your daughter. 174 00:08:39,520 --> 00:08:40,200 Is that correct? 175 00:08:43,289 --> 00:08:45,580 Yeah. 176 00:08:45,191 --> 00:08:47,293 Do you mind if I ask you who ended the marriage? 177 00:08:49,229 --> 00:08:50,130 She did. 178 00:08:51,531 --> 00:08:53,299 Thank you. All you. 179 00:08:53,433 --> 00:08:55,350 Mr. Kemp. 180 00:08:56,636 --> 00:08:57,904 And you're a magazine writer? 181 00:08:58,380 --> 00:08:59,305 [Justin] Uh, that's right. 182 00:08:59,439 --> 00:09:00,674 What kind of articles do you write? 183 00:09:00,807 --> 00:09:02,275 Features, mostly. 184 00:09:02,409 --> 00:09:03,877 So you write about a variety of topics? 185 00:09:04,100 --> 00:09:05,278 Yes. 186 00:09:05,412 --> 00:09:08,810 Ever written about a murder trial? 187 00:09:08,214 --> 00:09:11,451 Uh, well, I write for a regional lifestyle magazine 188 00:09:11,584 --> 00:09:13,453 so it's not exactly Vanity Fair. 189 00:09:13,586 --> 00:09:15,121 [jurors chuckling] 190 00:09:15,255 --> 00:09:16,790 Take that as a no. 191 00:09:16,923 --> 00:09:19,590 Being a writer, I imagine you read a lot. 192 00:09:19,192 --> 00:09:21,161 You've read anything about this case? 193 00:09:21,294 --> 00:09:23,329 No. No. Today's the first I've heard about it. 194 00:09:24,431 --> 00:09:25,999 Well, then, I think you'll make 195 00:09:26,132 --> 00:09:29,135 a perfectly acceptable member of this jury. 196 00:09:29,269 --> 00:09:31,971 All right. Does the defense accept or challenge? 197 00:09:33,440 --> 00:09:36,209 We accept him, Your Honor. 198 00:09:36,343 --> 00:09:40,814 Good. Please enter Justin Kemp as juror number two. 199 00:09:43,616 --> 00:09:44,984 - [Justin] Hey. - [Ally] Hi! 200 00:09:45,118 --> 00:09:46,820 - [Justin] Hi. - [Ally] How did it go? 201 00:09:46,953 --> 00:09:48,188 - [sighs] - [Ally] No. 202 00:09:48,321 --> 00:09:49,856 - I got picked. - No. 203 00:09:49,989 --> 00:09:51,324 - Mmm. - I'm so sorry. 204 00:09:51,458 --> 00:09:52,826 I know. 205 00:09:52,959 --> 00:09:54,127 What happened to "wildly inappropriate"? 206 00:09:54,260 --> 00:09:55,128 Ah. Well, I'm saving that for you. 207 00:09:55,261 --> 00:09:57,970 Oh, yeah? 208 00:09:57,230 --> 00:09:59,432 They said it'll be a short trial. 209 00:09:59,566 --> 00:10:00,800 I feel like they always say that, 210 00:10:00,934 --> 00:10:02,369 - but I hope so. - I know. 211 00:10:03,169 --> 00:10:04,371 How was your day? 212 00:10:04,504 --> 00:10:06,740 It was okay. I did this. [laughs] 213 00:10:06,873 --> 00:10:08,842 Yeah? It's good progress. Looks good. 214 00:10:08,975 --> 00:10:10,810 - [laughs] Thank you. - All day? 215 00:10:10,944 --> 00:10:12,278 No, this did not take me all day. 216 00:10:12,412 --> 00:10:14,180 - Yeah. - I watched a documentary... 217 00:10:14,314 --> 00:10:17,650 - Mmm-hmm. What about? - ...and I peed 94 times. 218 00:10:17,784 --> 00:10:20,253 - Ninety-four? Okay. - And I ate some ice. 219 00:10:20,387 --> 00:10:21,521 - Ooh. - Can I have some more? 220 00:10:21,654 --> 00:10:22,622 - You need some more? Ice? - Yeah. 221 00:10:22,756 --> 00:10:24,157 Ice. Coming up. All right. 222 00:10:27,227 --> 00:10:28,795 [exhales] 223 00:10:37,671 --> 00:10:40,740 The people need to know how I'll make this city safer. 224 00:10:40,874 --> 00:10:42,742 And women need to know that, 225 00:10:42,876 --> 00:10:44,544 if they're in an abusive relationship, 226 00:10:44,678 --> 00:10:46,790 their community has their back. 227 00:10:46,212 --> 00:10:48,348 The rest? The rest is noise. 228 00:10:48,481 --> 00:10:49,683 So, thank you. 229 00:10:52,952 --> 00:10:55,422 Thank you, guys. Thank you for coming. 230 00:10:56,589 --> 00:10:57,857 Thank you. Thank you so much. 231 00:10:57,991 --> 00:11:00,460 Thank you. Hey! Thank you so much. 232 00:11:00,593 --> 00:11:01,961 Thank you. I really appreciate it. 233 00:11:02,950 --> 00:11:03,430 Thank you so much. Yeah. 234 00:11:05,650 --> 00:11:06,399 [man] Hey. Good job. 235 00:11:10,603 --> 00:11:12,872 - [sighs] Hey. - Hey. 236 00:11:13,707 --> 00:11:14,674 Nice speech. 237 00:11:14,808 --> 00:11:16,309 [chuckles] 238 00:11:18,411 --> 00:11:19,612 Thanks. 239 00:11:19,746 --> 00:11:21,748 "Justice is truth in action"? 240 00:11:21,881 --> 00:11:23,983 Mmm-hmm. Professor Nielsen. 241 00:11:24,117 --> 00:11:26,119 Yeah. No. Yeah, I remember. 242 00:11:27,587 --> 00:11:28,722 You still believe it? 243 00:11:30,657 --> 00:11:31,825 Of course. 244 00:11:33,259 --> 00:11:34,661 All right. As long as it doesn't 245 00:11:34,794 --> 00:11:36,730 get in the way of a win, though, right? 246 00:11:36,863 --> 00:11:39,199 Oh, my God. If you got something to say, Eric, just say it. 247 00:11:39,332 --> 00:11:42,200 Mmm. I'm saying, he... 248 00:11:42,135 --> 00:11:44,337 You know, he loves you. You were his favorite student. 249 00:11:44,938 --> 00:11:45,939 [scoffs] 250 00:11:46,720 --> 00:11:47,474 Are you really going there? 251 00:11:47,607 --> 00:11:49,943 - Yeah, I'm going there. - Oh, my God! 252 00:11:50,760 --> 00:11:51,578 And now you're a... 253 00:11:53,480 --> 00:11:54,481 What? 254 00:11:55,148 --> 00:11:56,549 I'm a what? 255 00:11:56,683 --> 00:11:58,251 A politician. [sighs] 256 00:12:02,522 --> 00:12:03,790 [Judge Thelma] Good morning. 257 00:12:03,923 --> 00:12:05,658 We will begin with opening statements. 258 00:12:05,792 --> 00:12:07,270 Ms. Killebrew. 259 00:12:09,796 --> 00:12:12,665 Okay. The facts of the case are these. 260 00:12:12,799 --> 00:12:16,202 One year ago, on October 25th, the defendant, James Sythe, 261 00:12:16,336 --> 00:12:18,738 and his then-girlfriend, Kendall Carter, 262 00:12:18,872 --> 00:12:20,373 went drinking at Rowdy's Hideaway 263 00:12:20,507 --> 00:12:21,608 on Old Quarry Road. 264 00:12:25,145 --> 00:12:27,180 [country rock music playing on speakers] 265 00:12:30,250 --> 00:12:32,520 Come on. I walked all the way up there and got it. 266 00:12:32,185 --> 00:12:33,920 - Take the drink. - I'm already drunk, babe. 267 00:12:35,355 --> 00:12:36,389 [chuckles] 268 00:12:42,796 --> 00:12:44,297 [inaudible conversation] 269 00:12:50,337 --> 00:12:52,138 Things got tense. 270 00:12:52,272 --> 00:12:53,540 They had a fight. 271 00:12:53,673 --> 00:12:54,708 [Kendall] Not fair what you're doing. 272 00:12:54,841 --> 00:12:56,209 [James] Hey, leave it alone. 273 00:12:56,343 --> 00:12:58,111 [Kendall] What the hell is wrong with you? 274 00:12:58,244 --> 00:12:59,312 [James] I've already told you. We're not moving in together. 275 00:12:59,446 --> 00:13:00,747 [Kendall] I'm not... 276 00:13:00,880 --> 00:13:02,315 - What is wrong with it? - Stop pushing me. 277 00:13:02,449 --> 00:13:03,583 - I told you, stop... - I'm not pushing you. 278 00:13:03,717 --> 00:13:04,384 - [gasps] - I said stop pushing! 279 00:13:04,517 --> 00:13:05,785 [scoffs] 280 00:13:09,522 --> 00:13:11,910 Jesus Christ. 281 00:13:11,224 --> 00:13:12,892 [Faith] She stormed out of the bar 282 00:13:13,260 --> 00:13:14,427 and he followed her. 283 00:13:16,996 --> 00:13:18,331 The fight escalated, 284 00:13:18,465 --> 00:13:20,400 and things quickly got out of control. 285 00:13:22,102 --> 00:13:23,770 Hey. 286 00:13:23,903 --> 00:13:25,238 What the hell are you doing? 287 00:13:25,372 --> 00:13:27,140 - What are you doing? - Get away from me. 288 00:13:27,273 --> 00:13:28,541 Don't touch me. 289 00:13:28,675 --> 00:13:30,377 - How dare you? - Are you kidding me? 290 00:13:37,830 --> 00:13:39,185 [Eric] It was par for the course. 291 00:13:39,319 --> 00:13:41,210 They'd argue. They'd break up. 292 00:13:41,154 --> 00:13:42,622 And they'd make up the next day 293 00:13:42,756 --> 00:13:44,157 after they both had calmed down. 294 00:13:44,290 --> 00:13:47,360 It was basically a game. 295 00:13:47,494 --> 00:13:50,497 [Faith] Now, this couple had a history of violent interactions, 296 00:13:50,630 --> 00:13:53,600 but this time she was serious. 297 00:13:53,733 --> 00:13:55,201 She was done with him. 298 00:13:55,335 --> 00:13:58,805 So she left and headed down the road, on foot. 299 00:14:03,510 --> 00:14:05,812 [tense music playing] 300 00:14:12,285 --> 00:14:15,822 [Eric] So this was just another typical night of drama. 301 00:14:15,955 --> 00:14:19,426 So James Sythe got in his car and he drove home. 302 00:14:21,461 --> 00:14:24,130 He flew into a violent rage 303 00:14:24,264 --> 00:14:27,333 and followed Kendall Carter down the road... 304 00:14:28,902 --> 00:14:30,837 where he proceeded to kill her. 305 00:14:36,576 --> 00:14:38,178 [cell phone chimes] 306 00:14:39,245 --> 00:14:40,380 - [thuds] - [grunts] 307 00:14:40,513 --> 00:14:43,160 - [gasping] - [tires screeching] 308 00:14:45,785 --> 00:14:47,153 [breathing heavily] 309 00:14:51,570 --> 00:14:53,727 [Faith] He beat her viciously. 310 00:14:53,860 --> 00:14:56,463 He pushed her over a railing to the creek below... 311 00:14:58,640 --> 00:14:59,366 and left her to die. 312 00:15:00,660 --> 00:15:01,534 [jurors exclaim] 313 00:15:38,171 --> 00:15:40,730 [panting] 314 00:15:46,913 --> 00:15:48,848 James Sythe didn't attack her 315 00:15:48,982 --> 00:15:50,684 and he couldn't have pushed her 316 00:15:50,817 --> 00:15:53,530 because he wasn't there. 317 00:15:56,189 --> 00:15:58,558 [somber music playing] 318 00:15:58,692 --> 00:16:00,393 James Sythe... 319 00:16:01,961 --> 00:16:02,962 [sighs] 320 00:16:03,960 --> 00:16:04,264 took an innocent life. 321 00:16:05,732 --> 00:16:07,400 James Sythe... 322 00:16:07,534 --> 00:16:08,735 is an innocent man. 323 00:16:12,772 --> 00:16:13,973 Thank you. 324 00:16:21,140 --> 00:16:23,216 [retching] 325 00:16:26,519 --> 00:16:27,587 [flushes] 326 00:16:27,721 --> 00:16:29,255 [sighing] 327 00:16:39,566 --> 00:16:41,468 Damn, man. 328 00:16:41,601 --> 00:16:43,269 - You... You all right? - Mmm-hmm. 329 00:16:44,637 --> 00:16:46,906 Yeah. Just those crime scene pictures. 330 00:16:47,907 --> 00:16:49,242 Never had a strong stomach. 331 00:16:50,210 --> 00:16:51,845 Yeah. 332 00:16:51,978 --> 00:16:53,580 All right. Well, you have a good night. 333 00:16:54,214 --> 00:16:55,215 You, too. 334 00:17:09,496 --> 00:17:10,930 [all] God grant me the serenity 335 00:17:11,640 --> 00:17:13,666 to accept the things that I cannot change, 336 00:17:13,800 --> 00:17:16,469 the courage to change the things that I can, 337 00:17:16,603 --> 00:17:19,500 and the wisdom to know the difference. 338 00:17:20,407 --> 00:17:21,508 Great work, everybody. 339 00:17:21,641 --> 00:17:23,900 Keep coming back. 340 00:17:23,143 --> 00:17:25,111 [all] It works if you work it. 341 00:17:25,245 --> 00:17:26,446 Great job, everybody. 342 00:17:27,614 --> 00:17:28,615 [man] Right on, bro! 343 00:17:31,451 --> 00:17:32,819 Hey, Justin. 344 00:17:32,952 --> 00:17:33,987 Hey! 345 00:17:34,120 --> 00:17:35,422 You were quiet tonight. 346 00:17:35,555 --> 00:17:37,657 Yeah. I've got a lot on my mind. 347 00:17:37,791 --> 00:17:39,325 Yeah, I can tell. [chuckles] 348 00:17:39,459 --> 00:17:42,620 You want to talk about it? 349 00:17:42,195 --> 00:17:45,331 Okay, look, whatever it is, my advice is the same. 350 00:17:45,465 --> 00:17:47,333 You know what to do. 351 00:17:47,467 --> 00:17:49,169 We're only as sick as our secrets. 352 00:17:50,170 --> 00:17:51,204 Yeah. 353 00:17:51,338 --> 00:17:52,505 Okay, I'm always here for you. 354 00:18:06,820 --> 00:18:08,388 [tense music playing] 355 00:18:40,720 --> 00:18:42,222 [man] Working late? 356 00:18:42,355 --> 00:18:43,390 [keyboard clacks] 357 00:18:43,523 --> 00:18:44,924 Be out of your way in a minute. 358 00:18:45,580 --> 00:18:46,192 Nah, take as long as you want, I'll come back. 359 00:19:12,218 --> 00:19:14,540 - Hey. - Hey. 360 00:19:14,187 --> 00:19:16,589 - Sorry I'm late. - That's okay. 361 00:19:16,723 --> 00:19:17,791 How was the meeting? 362 00:19:17,924 --> 00:19:19,359 It was good. 363 00:19:19,492 --> 00:19:21,361 I stayed after to talk with Larry for a bit. 364 00:19:21,494 --> 00:19:22,729 [breathing heavily] 365 00:19:22,862 --> 00:19:24,264 You okay? Your heart. 366 00:19:24,397 --> 00:19:26,599 - Hmm? - Are you okay? 367 00:19:27,967 --> 00:19:28,968 Yeah, I'm good. 368 00:19:30,270 --> 00:19:31,905 Everything's going to be fine. 369 00:19:33,573 --> 00:19:35,375 We're going to be a family soon. 370 00:19:35,508 --> 00:19:37,430 [Justin] Hmm. 371 00:19:37,177 --> 00:19:39,279 Very soon, I hope. [chuckles] 372 00:19:40,800 --> 00:19:42,515 [sighing] 373 00:19:48,888 --> 00:19:51,624 - [tires screeching] - [gasping] 374 00:19:51,758 --> 00:19:52,792 [breathing heavily] 375 00:19:52,926 --> 00:19:53,893 What the... 376 00:20:07,374 --> 00:20:09,743 I'd seen them in there before. A couple times. 377 00:20:09,876 --> 00:20:12,345 Um, it was always the same thing. 378 00:20:12,479 --> 00:20:15,448 They would start off fun and flirty, and then, 379 00:20:15,582 --> 00:20:17,984 after a few drinks, things would change. 380 00:20:18,118 --> 00:20:19,753 Change, how? 381 00:20:19,886 --> 00:20:22,880 That night, she came in, 382 00:20:22,222 --> 00:20:26,126 trying to talk to him, like, seriously, you know? 383 00:20:26,259 --> 00:20:29,129 But he wasn't having it. 384 00:20:29,262 --> 00:20:30,463 [Kendall] What's wrong with you? 385 00:20:30,597 --> 00:20:31,965 What, do you want me to disagree? 386 00:20:32,980 --> 00:20:33,566 No. I want you to say, "I love you, too." 387 00:20:34,467 --> 00:20:35,769 I basically did. 388 00:20:35,902 --> 00:20:36,936 I want you to say, "I love you, too." 389 00:20:37,700 --> 00:20:38,371 Read between the goddamn lines, 390 00:20:38,505 --> 00:20:40,140 I said, "Yeah." 391 00:20:40,273 --> 00:20:41,675 - [Kendall] What lines? - [James] I'm sick of this shit. 392 00:20:41,808 --> 00:20:43,900 [Kendall] What lines are you talking about? 393 00:20:43,143 --> 00:20:43,810 [James] Hey, get out of my face! 394 00:20:43,943 --> 00:20:45,311 [Kendall gasps] 395 00:20:45,445 --> 00:20:48,882 [woman] He got mad. Like, scary. 396 00:20:49,150 --> 00:20:50,417 She leaves. 397 00:20:52,652 --> 00:20:55,822 He follows her outside. So I started following. 398 00:20:55,955 --> 00:20:56,956 Hey! 399 00:20:58,240 --> 00:20:59,426 What the hell are you doing? 400 00:20:59,559 --> 00:21:00,860 What are you doing? 401 00:21:00,994 --> 00:21:01,995 I want to go home. 402 00:21:04,300 --> 00:21:06,320 - I don't want to do this anymore. - [James] Do what? 403 00:21:06,166 --> 00:21:08,168 [Kendall] I'm done. You're embarrassing! 404 00:21:08,301 --> 00:21:09,469 What are you talking about? 405 00:21:09,602 --> 00:21:10,804 Who cares what these idiots think? 406 00:21:13,106 --> 00:21:14,941 What are you going to do? Hit me? 407 00:21:15,750 --> 00:21:16,376 - Relax. I'm sorry. - Don't touch me. 408 00:21:16,509 --> 00:21:17,744 - It was... - What are you going to do? 409 00:21:17,877 --> 00:21:19,713 - How dare you? - Are you kidding me? 410 00:21:19,846 --> 00:21:20,847 Bring it on! 411 00:21:23,216 --> 00:21:25,510 You better get the **** out of here right now. 412 00:21:26,386 --> 00:21:27,987 [crowd murmuring] 413 00:21:28,121 --> 00:21:31,758 Fine, walk home, in the rain, you stupid *****! 414 00:21:35,161 --> 00:21:37,397 - And, Kendall, we ain't over! - I'm done, James. 415 00:21:39,199 --> 00:21:41,368 [crowd murmuring] 416 00:21:46,606 --> 00:21:48,475 So she left, 417 00:21:48,608 --> 00:21:50,110 then what happened? 418 00:21:50,243 --> 00:21:52,212 He followed her out of the parking lot 419 00:21:52,345 --> 00:21:54,347 and onto Old Quarry Road. 420 00:21:54,481 --> 00:21:57,183 Thank you. No further questions, Your Honor. 421 00:21:58,885 --> 00:22:01,421 So you saw him walk down Old Quarry Road? 422 00:22:02,220 --> 00:22:03,757 Yes. 423 00:22:03,890 --> 00:22:05,225 Did you know that his car was parked 424 00:22:05,358 --> 00:22:06,393 down on Old Quarry Road? 425 00:22:07,761 --> 00:22:08,795 No. 426 00:22:09,829 --> 00:22:11,398 No. 427 00:22:11,531 --> 00:22:13,660 Were you drinking that night? 428 00:22:13,199 --> 00:22:14,401 Objection, Your Honor. 429 00:22:15,350 --> 00:22:16,670 Overruled. 430 00:22:16,803 --> 00:22:18,304 Were you drinking that night? 431 00:22:19,372 --> 00:22:20,674 Yes. 432 00:22:20,807 --> 00:22:23,576 So you don't know how far he followed her 433 00:22:23,710 --> 00:22:27,800 down Old Quarry Road, do you? 434 00:22:27,213 --> 00:22:28,782 No. Um, at that point, 435 00:22:28,915 --> 00:22:31,217 I had stopped filming and I went back inside. 436 00:22:32,552 --> 00:22:34,621 No more questions. 437 00:22:34,754 --> 00:22:37,190 [Judge Thelma] Does the State have any more questions? 438 00:22:37,323 --> 00:22:38,792 No more questions, Your Honor. 439 00:22:43,630 --> 00:22:45,398 [Judge Thelma] Thank you. You may step down. 440 00:22:45,532 --> 00:22:47,967 I was at the bar till close. 441 00:22:48,101 --> 00:22:50,804 I didn't see either one of them come back in. 442 00:22:50,937 --> 00:22:52,172 And then the next day, I opened, 443 00:22:52,305 --> 00:22:53,673 and I did what I always do. 444 00:22:53,807 --> 00:22:56,176 I took the night's trash out to the dumpster. 445 00:22:59,746 --> 00:23:02,749 Miss! Miss! I'm sorry. I need your help. 446 00:23:02,882 --> 00:23:05,785 Because of the rain the night before... 447 00:23:05,919 --> 00:23:08,121 the trails were all muddy and wet. 448 00:23:11,324 --> 00:23:13,259 So I had to cut up to Old Quarry by the bridge 449 00:23:13,393 --> 00:23:14,994 in order to get back to the road. 450 00:23:16,229 --> 00:23:17,864 [tense music playing] 451 00:23:19,265 --> 00:23:21,134 [breathing heavily] 452 00:23:33,146 --> 00:23:34,414 Right. And just to be clear, 453 00:23:34,547 --> 00:23:36,416 when you found Kendall Carter, 454 00:23:37,217 --> 00:23:38,485 she was dead? 455 00:23:40,787 --> 00:23:43,523 Her head was in a pool of blood. 456 00:23:44,758 --> 00:23:45,859 It was awful. 457 00:23:49,290 --> 00:23:50,563 Thank you for your testimony, Mr. Reed. 458 00:23:50,697 --> 00:23:51,865 I know it isn't easy. 459 00:23:53,366 --> 00:23:54,367 That's all I have. 460 00:23:56,670 --> 00:23:58,371 Mr. Resnick, your witness. 461 00:23:59,673 --> 00:24:01,474 Mr. Reed, 462 00:24:01,608 --> 00:24:04,310 you hike those trails in the woods frequently, don't you? 463 00:24:05,545 --> 00:24:06,613 Yes, sir. 464 00:24:06,746 --> 00:24:08,448 Twice a week at least. 465 00:24:08,581 --> 00:24:11,117 In your opinion, is the hike down the hillside difficult? 466 00:24:11,885 --> 00:24:13,687 Yes. 467 00:24:13,820 --> 00:24:15,588 I assume you wear hiking boots 468 00:24:15,722 --> 00:24:17,323 when you hike, Mr. Reed? Is that correct? 469 00:24:19,292 --> 00:24:20,593 Of course. 470 00:24:20,727 --> 00:24:23,797 This is a picture of Kendall Carter 471 00:24:23,930 --> 00:24:27,634 the morning you found her below Old Quarry Road. 472 00:24:27,767 --> 00:24:30,203 Can you please tell us what kind of shoes she's wearing? 473 00:24:33,340 --> 00:24:34,407 Looks like heels. 474 00:24:36,343 --> 00:24:38,445 Heels. 475 00:24:38,578 --> 00:24:41,281 And if she's walking along the edge of Old Quarry Road 476 00:24:41,414 --> 00:24:45,885 in a blinding rainstorm at night, in heels, 477 00:24:46,190 --> 00:24:49,122 and she suddenly lost her footing, 478 00:24:49,255 --> 00:24:51,570 it'd be next to impossible 479 00:24:51,191 --> 00:24:53,590 to prevent herself from falling, isn't that correct? 480 00:24:55,962 --> 00:24:56,896 Yes. 481 00:25:00,330 --> 00:25:00,967 Thank you. 482 00:25:02,936 --> 00:25:05,271 She landed in a posterior position, 483 00:25:05,405 --> 00:25:09,109 which suggests she was pushed, as opposed to a fall. 484 00:25:09,242 --> 00:25:11,478 Rigor mortis indicated the victim had been dead 485 00:25:11,611 --> 00:25:13,179 for around nine hours. 486 00:25:13,313 --> 00:25:14,514 [Faith] Hmm. 487 00:25:14,647 --> 00:25:16,490 And the cause of death? 488 00:25:16,182 --> 00:25:18,318 The severity of her skull fractures suggests 489 00:25:18,451 --> 00:25:21,554 she was struck with a non-specific blunt instrument. 490 00:25:22,956 --> 00:25:24,924 And the manner of death? 491 00:25:26,920 --> 00:25:27,930 Homicide. 492 00:25:29,396 --> 00:25:31,264 [Faith] Thank you. No more questions. 493 00:25:34,634 --> 00:25:37,237 The witness is yours, Mr. Resnick. 494 00:25:37,370 --> 00:25:39,305 Is it possible that she sustained 495 00:25:39,439 --> 00:25:41,474 her head injuries from hitting the rocks? 496 00:25:41,608 --> 00:25:43,309 Possible, sure, 497 00:25:43,443 --> 00:25:44,611 but in my professional opinion, it's not likely. 498 00:25:44,744 --> 00:25:46,212 But possible. 499 00:25:49,315 --> 00:25:50,283 That's all from me. 500 00:25:55,455 --> 00:25:58,580 Thank you for your testimony. You may step down. 501 00:26:02,429 --> 00:26:03,963 On October 25th of last year, 502 00:26:04,970 --> 00:26:05,465 you lived on Old Quarry Road. 503 00:26:05,598 --> 00:26:07,534 - Correct? - Yes. 504 00:26:07,667 --> 00:26:09,336 And do you remember anything unusual happening that evening? 505 00:26:09,469 --> 00:26:12,672 I saw a man get out of his car [chuckles] in a storm. 506 00:26:12,806 --> 00:26:14,740 Do you remember what time that was? 507 00:26:14,207 --> 00:26:16,343 It was 11:48 on the button. 508 00:26:17,210 --> 00:26:18,345 I looked at the clock. 509 00:26:19,145 --> 00:26:20,880 I heard thunder, 510 00:26:21,140 --> 00:26:23,350 and so I went to the window, and lightning lit up the sky. 511 00:26:24,818 --> 00:26:25,752 There he was. 512 00:26:25,885 --> 00:26:27,487 [Faith] What was he doing? 513 00:26:27,620 --> 00:26:30,824 He looked around, he went over to the side of the road. 514 00:26:33,360 --> 00:26:35,829 Peered over the railing... 515 00:26:35,962 --> 00:26:39,699 got back in his car and drove off. 516 00:26:39,833 --> 00:26:41,234 And is that man you saw that night 517 00:26:41,368 --> 00:26:42,736 here in the courtroom today, do you know? 518 00:26:42,869 --> 00:26:43,937 Can you point him out? 519 00:26:46,206 --> 00:26:47,207 [coin clatters] 520 00:26:49,175 --> 00:26:50,410 Yes, he is here today. 521 00:26:52,145 --> 00:26:54,581 That's him right there. 522 00:26:54,714 --> 00:26:56,850 Let the record reflect that the witness has identified 523 00:26:56,983 --> 00:26:59,190 the man he saw as the defendant, 524 00:26:59,152 --> 00:27:01,888 James Michael Sythe. 525 00:27:02,220 --> 00:27:03,356 No more questions, Your Honor. 526 00:27:05,291 --> 00:27:07,494 All right. This feels like a good time 527 00:27:07,627 --> 00:27:09,696 to break for the day. 528 00:27:09,829 --> 00:27:12,932 This court is in recess until 9:00 a.m. tomorrow morning 529 00:27:13,660 --> 00:27:15,802 when we will pick up here where we left off. 530 00:27:28,480 --> 00:27:29,820 Justin, what's going on? 531 00:27:31,217 --> 00:27:32,318 I need a lawyer. 532 00:27:34,287 --> 00:27:36,556 Okay. Give me a dollar. 533 00:27:36,690 --> 00:27:38,725 And I'm not joking, that gives us attorney-client privilege. 534 00:27:38,858 --> 00:27:39,859 Take a seat. 535 00:27:43,163 --> 00:27:44,998 So I went to clear my head, 536 00:27:45,131 --> 00:27:47,500 and found myself at Rowdy's Hideaway... 537 00:27:49,202 --> 00:27:50,970 Ordered a drink and sat there for a while, 538 00:27:51,104 --> 00:27:52,605 then I got up and left. 539 00:27:52,739 --> 00:27:55,608 I got to the car. It was raining. 540 00:27:55,742 --> 00:27:57,210 I turned back onto Old Quarry, 541 00:27:57,344 --> 00:27:59,279 I went about a quarter of a mile 542 00:27:59,412 --> 00:28:00,747 and I hit something. 543 00:28:02,315 --> 00:28:03,516 I got out of the car and I looked around. 544 00:28:03,650 --> 00:28:05,180 I checked, I didn't see anything, 545 00:28:05,151 --> 00:28:07,554 and I figured it was a deer that ran off, 546 00:28:07,687 --> 00:28:10,457 and then I got back in the car and went home. 547 00:28:13,693 --> 00:28:15,862 Okay, what's the problem? 548 00:28:15,995 --> 00:28:18,310 I got called for jury duty. 549 00:28:18,164 --> 00:28:20,600 - The Kendall Carter case? - Mmm-hmm. 550 00:28:20,734 --> 00:28:24,700 And they found her body in a creek bed, 551 00:28:24,204 --> 00:28:26,940 about a quarter mile from Rowdy's Hideaway last October. 552 00:28:29,976 --> 00:28:31,177 What are you telling me? 553 00:28:32,178 --> 00:28:33,613 [breathes heavily] 554 00:28:34,647 --> 00:28:35,949 Maybe I didn't hit a deer. 555 00:28:37,517 --> 00:28:38,518 [sighs] 556 00:28:39,953 --> 00:28:41,488 [stammers] I don't know what to do. 557 00:28:43,556 --> 00:28:44,924 You were at a bar and you had a drink? 558 00:28:45,580 --> 00:28:46,493 Yes, but I didn't touch it. 559 00:28:46,626 --> 00:28:47,794 Doesn't matter. 560 00:28:47,927 --> 00:28:49,129 Given your history, 561 00:28:49,262 --> 00:28:50,563 there isn't a jury in the world 562 00:28:50,697 --> 00:28:52,198 that would believe you were sober. 563 00:28:52,332 --> 00:28:53,833 But if I was coming forward voluntarily, 564 00:28:53,967 --> 00:28:55,468 that has to count for something, right? 565 00:28:55,602 --> 00:28:56,770 If I come forward and I tell them the truth... 566 00:28:56,903 --> 00:28:58,138 Then your prior DUIs, 567 00:28:58,271 --> 00:28:59,773 and the fact that you were at a bar, 568 00:28:59,906 --> 00:29:01,107 gives the State reason to charge you 569 00:29:01,241 --> 00:29:02,575 with first-degree vehicular homicide 570 00:29:02,709 --> 00:29:03,810 or even felony murder. 571 00:29:03,943 --> 00:29:05,712 That's 30 years to life. 572 00:29:05,845 --> 00:29:07,147 What? 573 00:29:07,280 --> 00:29:08,648 If you were to come forward right now, 574 00:29:08,782 --> 00:29:10,183 you will be completely screwed. 575 00:29:12,752 --> 00:29:13,687 That's it? 576 00:29:13,820 --> 00:29:14,821 Uh... 577 00:29:17,290 --> 00:29:18,258 [sighs] 578 00:29:19,159 --> 00:29:20,160 I'm sorry. 579 00:29:22,996 --> 00:29:25,365 [Eric] The defense calls James Sythe, Your Honor. 580 00:29:28,802 --> 00:29:31,710 [Judge Thelma] Please raise your right hand. 581 00:29:31,204 --> 00:29:32,839 Do you swear to tell the truth, 582 00:29:32,972 --> 00:29:35,108 the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, 583 00:29:35,241 --> 00:29:36,276 so help you God? 584 00:29:36,409 --> 00:29:37,577 Yes, Your Honor. 585 00:29:37,711 --> 00:29:39,946 All right. Have a seat. 586 00:29:43,216 --> 00:29:45,518 Please state your name for the record. 587 00:29:45,652 --> 00:29:47,387 Uh, James Michael Sythe. 588 00:29:49,723 --> 00:29:51,191 [Judge Thelma] Mr. Resnick, your witness. 589 00:29:51,324 --> 00:29:53,693 Okay, James, let's talk about what happened 590 00:29:53,827 --> 00:29:55,228 the night of October 25th. 591 00:29:55,362 --> 00:29:56,496 Can you tell us what happened? 592 00:29:56,629 --> 00:29:58,398 Yeah, um... 593 00:29:58,531 --> 00:29:59,933 Kendall and I went to Rowdy's 594 00:30:00,660 --> 00:30:02,602 to have a few drinks, get some food. 595 00:30:03,970 --> 00:30:06,390 We were having fun, shots and pool, 596 00:30:06,172 --> 00:30:08,308 played some darts, you know. 597 00:30:08,441 --> 00:30:11,711 Now, there's been testimony that you guys argued. 598 00:30:11,845 --> 00:30:13,913 You don't deny that, do you? 599 00:30:14,470 --> 00:30:16,820 [James] No. No, yeah. Um... 600 00:30:16,216 --> 00:30:18,885 She got really drunk and she was... 601 00:30:19,190 --> 00:30:20,860 She was giving me a hard time. 602 00:30:20,954 --> 00:30:22,822 What do you mean? 603 00:30:22,956 --> 00:30:25,325 She'd been going on about us moving in together 604 00:30:25,458 --> 00:30:27,930 for a couple of weeks and I... 605 00:30:27,227 --> 00:30:28,795 just kept telling her that I didn't think 606 00:30:28,928 --> 00:30:30,530 that I was ready. 607 00:30:30,663 --> 00:30:31,631 We'll... We'll see. 608 00:30:33,366 --> 00:30:35,335 - We'll see. - What do you mean "We'll see"? 609 00:30:35,468 --> 00:30:37,904 And she just wasn't having it. She said I didn't love her. 610 00:30:39,806 --> 00:30:41,341 And, uh, she stormed out. 611 00:30:41,474 --> 00:30:42,809 And then what happened? 612 00:30:44,100 --> 00:30:46,460 We argued in the parking lot. 613 00:30:46,179 --> 00:30:47,580 I don't want to do this anymore. 614 00:30:47,714 --> 00:30:49,549 - Do what? - I want to go home. 615 00:30:50,250 --> 00:30:51,518 I'm done. 616 00:30:51,651 --> 00:30:52,986 Fine. Get out of here. Go walk home. 617 00:30:55,121 --> 00:30:57,357 Go walk home then. In the rain. 618 00:31:01,940 --> 00:31:03,430 And she was just out of her head, you know? 619 00:31:03,563 --> 00:31:05,832 Screaming at me and walked off. 620 00:31:06,966 --> 00:31:09,350 [Eric] And what did you do? 621 00:31:09,169 --> 00:31:11,400 [James] Followed her, at first, 622 00:31:11,137 --> 00:31:13,606 but it was cold, it was raining. 623 00:31:14,908 --> 00:31:16,943 I remember getting in my car. 624 00:31:17,770 --> 00:31:18,511 So I was parked next to, uh, 625 00:31:18,645 --> 00:31:20,246 mile marker 217. 626 00:31:23,450 --> 00:31:27,153 My niece is born February 17th, so that just... 627 00:31:29,356 --> 00:31:31,458 I don't know, pulled me out of everything, 628 00:31:31,591 --> 00:31:34,194 then I turned around and just drove home. 629 00:31:41,167 --> 00:31:44,137 And, um, we'd see each other the next day, 630 00:31:44,270 --> 00:31:45,805 and we'd work it out, like... 631 00:31:47,307 --> 00:31:48,308 like always. 632 00:31:50,276 --> 00:31:53,813 Look, was I stupid? 633 00:31:53,947 --> 00:31:56,483 For not wanting to move in with her? 634 00:31:56,616 --> 00:31:58,485 So I could see her face every day? 635 00:32:00,487 --> 00:32:01,454 Absolutely, yeah. 636 00:32:03,356 --> 00:32:05,625 But I could never put my hands on her like that. 637 00:32:09,996 --> 00:32:11,531 I couldn't do that to her. 638 00:32:12,565 --> 00:32:13,767 I... I loved her. 639 00:32:16,469 --> 00:32:19,205 Now, look, I understand, 640 00:32:19,339 --> 00:32:22,375 with my past, and the mistakes that I've made, 641 00:32:22,509 --> 00:32:25,110 I know what you're thinking, I do. And I get it. 642 00:32:27,847 --> 00:32:29,516 But I'm... 643 00:32:29,649 --> 00:32:31,351 I'm not that guy anymore. 644 00:32:32,485 --> 00:32:33,687 Okay, I've changed. 645 00:32:35,689 --> 00:32:37,691 I left that life behind me, and I, you know... 646 00:32:37,824 --> 00:32:39,526 [voice breaks] I thought I was doing really good. 647 00:32:41,494 --> 00:32:44,970 [sighs] I don't know what happened. 648 00:32:45,310 --> 00:32:46,132 I went home. I drove... 649 00:32:46,266 --> 00:32:47,534 I just... I drove home. 650 00:32:54,740 --> 00:32:56,760 I know how difficult this is for you, James. 651 00:32:58,178 --> 00:33:00,460 You take your time, and... 652 00:33:00,180 --> 00:33:01,581 let me know when you're ready. 653 00:33:03,483 --> 00:33:04,451 I'm good. 654 00:33:06,920 --> 00:33:09,356 I'm gonna show you a video now, okay? 655 00:33:09,489 --> 00:33:11,124 And then I'm gonna ask you some questions. 656 00:33:13,226 --> 00:33:15,328 [James on video] It's fine. I'm not mad. 657 00:33:15,462 --> 00:33:16,996 Why didn't you say it to me? 658 00:33:17,130 --> 00:33:18,765 [country music playing on video] 659 00:33:19,766 --> 00:33:20,800 [billiard balls clatter] 660 00:33:22,602 --> 00:33:24,137 Did you see that? 661 00:33:24,270 --> 00:33:25,872 - That's for you. - [Kendall] That's my guy. 662 00:33:27,140 --> 00:33:28,475 [chuckles] 663 00:33:28,608 --> 00:33:30,844 - I love you. - I love you, too. 664 00:33:30,977 --> 00:33:32,112 Did you miss or make it? 665 00:33:32,245 --> 00:33:33,146 [Kendall] No, I didn't make it. 666 00:33:33,279 --> 00:33:34,948 [James] You missed it. 667 00:33:35,810 --> 00:33:37,384 Well, let me help you. You're good luck. Come here. 668 00:33:38,118 --> 00:33:39,850 [Kendall] I was. 669 00:33:41,888 --> 00:33:42,922 [Kendall kisses] 670 00:33:46,426 --> 00:33:47,861 [James] Okay, turn that shit off. 671 00:33:47,994 --> 00:33:49,195 [Kendall] Okay. 672 00:33:52,966 --> 00:33:53,967 [Eric] Who took that video? 673 00:33:54,934 --> 00:33:55,935 Kendall. 674 00:33:57,937 --> 00:33:58,872 When? 675 00:33:59,500 --> 00:34:00,340 October 25th. 676 00:34:01,508 --> 00:34:02,509 Of last year. 677 00:34:03,143 --> 00:34:04,310 And where? 678 00:34:05,578 --> 00:34:07,347 At Rowdy's Hideaway. 679 00:34:10,717 --> 00:34:12,752 Thank you, James. No more questions. 680 00:34:16,656 --> 00:34:18,158 Prosecution, your witness. 681 00:34:18,925 --> 00:34:20,393 Mr. Sythe, 682 00:34:20,527 --> 00:34:23,329 you just stated that you loved Kendall Carter. 683 00:34:23,463 --> 00:34:25,231 Is that right? 684 00:34:25,365 --> 00:34:27,500 - More than anything. - [Faith] Hmm. 685 00:34:27,634 --> 00:34:29,269 And on the night of October 25th, 686 00:34:29,402 --> 00:34:31,370 you and Kendall drove to Rowdy's Hideaway. 687 00:34:31,171 --> 00:34:32,105 Is that right? 688 00:34:32,238 --> 00:34:34,674 We took my car, yeah. 689 00:34:34,808 --> 00:34:35,942 And when you got there, the two of you 690 00:34:36,760 --> 00:34:37,310 started drinking, is that right? 691 00:34:38,478 --> 00:34:40,613 Yeah. It's a bar. 692 00:34:40,747 --> 00:34:42,549 And then the two of you started arguing. 693 00:34:42,682 --> 00:34:43,717 Is that right? 694 00:34:44,484 --> 00:34:45,318 Yeah. 695 00:34:46,853 --> 00:34:48,254 And during this argument, 696 00:34:48,388 --> 00:34:50,724 you knocked a beer bottle off the table. 697 00:34:50,857 --> 00:34:51,991 Is that right? 698 00:34:53,493 --> 00:34:55,562 Yeah, it was an accident. 699 00:34:55,695 --> 00:34:58,732 And then she left, and you went after her. 700 00:34:58,865 --> 00:34:59,766 Is that right? 701 00:34:59,899 --> 00:35:01,468 Yeah. 702 00:35:01,601 --> 00:35:05,710 And outside, the argument continued, and... [scoffs] 703 00:35:05,205 --> 00:35:07,340 it is your sworn testimony, 704 00:35:07,474 --> 00:35:09,743 that you left Kendall Carter alone 705 00:35:09,876 --> 00:35:12,145 to walk down a narrow two-lane road 706 00:35:12,278 --> 00:35:15,181 in the dark, drunk, in the pouring rain, 707 00:35:15,315 --> 00:35:17,217 in the middle of a thunderstorm. 708 00:35:19,319 --> 00:35:21,221 Is that how you treat someone you love? 709 00:35:26,920 --> 00:35:27,360 No more questions, Your Honor. 710 00:35:30,263 --> 00:35:32,499 Are there any further questions from the defense? 711 00:35:32,632 --> 00:35:35,602 No, Your Honor. The defense rests. 712 00:35:35,735 --> 00:35:38,672 Thank you for your testimony, you can step down. 713 00:35:47,580 --> 00:35:48,882 [Judge Thelma] Members of the jury, 714 00:35:49,150 --> 00:35:51,151 the evidence in this case is now closed. 715 00:35:51,284 --> 00:35:52,585 Attorneys, you may give 716 00:35:52,719 --> 00:35:54,954 your closing arguments at this time. 717 00:35:55,880 --> 00:35:57,157 Ladies and gentlemen of the jury... 718 00:35:59,920 --> 00:36:02,729 Kendall Carter's murder was a savage crime 719 00:36:02,862 --> 00:36:04,731 committed by an evil man. 720 00:36:05,832 --> 00:36:07,567 [Eric] An innocent man. 721 00:36:07,701 --> 00:36:11,304 An innocent man who was shattered 722 00:36:11,438 --> 00:36:14,874 from losing the love of his life. 723 00:36:15,800 --> 00:36:17,770 We have an eyewitness who saw him at the crime scene 724 00:36:17,210 --> 00:36:19,312 at the time of death. 725 00:36:19,446 --> 00:36:22,615 In the middle of the night, in a blinding rainstorm... 726 00:36:23,650 --> 00:36:24,984 it could have been anyone. 727 00:36:25,118 --> 00:36:26,986 When she broke up with him that night, 728 00:36:27,120 --> 00:36:29,589 and he realized she meant it, 729 00:36:29,723 --> 00:36:30,790 he snapped. 730 00:36:32,158 --> 00:36:33,793 And so he bludgeoned her. 731 00:36:33,927 --> 00:36:37,230 No murder weapon was recovered. Nothing. 732 00:36:38,310 --> 00:36:39,399 Nothing. 733 00:36:39,532 --> 00:36:42,502 The defendant's DNA was all over the victim. 734 00:36:42,635 --> 00:36:43,903 No one else's. 735 00:36:44,370 --> 00:36:45,672 [Eric] The State says there was DNA. 736 00:36:45,805 --> 00:36:48,308 Of course, there was DNA. Of course. 737 00:36:48,441 --> 00:36:49,809 They were a couple. 738 00:36:49,943 --> 00:36:52,312 [Faith] Yeah, of course, they were a couple. 739 00:36:52,445 --> 00:36:53,980 Until they weren't. 740 00:36:54,114 --> 00:36:58,118 James Sythe bravely took the stand 741 00:36:58,251 --> 00:37:00,720 and admitted to some difficult truths. 742 00:37:00,854 --> 00:37:02,288 [Faith] That? [scoffs] 743 00:37:02,422 --> 00:37:05,158 That was all a performance, nothing else. 744 00:37:05,925 --> 00:37:07,694 Look... 745 00:37:07,827 --> 00:37:10,997 I think we can all agree on this. 746 00:37:11,131 --> 00:37:14,334 The person responsible for Kendall Carter's death 747 00:37:15,301 --> 00:37:16,970 deserves to face justice. 748 00:37:18,710 --> 00:37:20,306 That person is James Sythe. 749 00:37:21,474 --> 00:37:22,575 But that person, 750 00:37:23,677 --> 00:37:24,911 that evil man, 751 00:37:26,146 --> 00:37:27,414 is still out there. 752 00:37:29,282 --> 00:37:32,485 All I ask is that you deliver a verdict 753 00:37:32,619 --> 00:37:33,920 that speaks the truth. 754 00:37:35,388 --> 00:37:38,291 The truth about what happened to Kendall. 755 00:37:38,425 --> 00:37:41,610 The truth about what happened on Old Quarry Road that night. 756 00:37:42,662 --> 00:37:44,164 And the truth about him. 757 00:37:47,867 --> 00:37:49,235 And the truth about him... 758 00:37:50,503 --> 00:37:52,439 is that James Michael Sythe 759 00:37:53,540 --> 00:37:54,541 is guilty. 760 00:37:55,575 --> 00:37:57,177 Find him guilty. 761 00:37:59,145 --> 00:38:01,715 The truth is, James Sythe... 762 00:38:02,549 --> 00:38:04,384 is not guilty. 763 00:38:07,554 --> 00:38:08,922 Find James Sythe... 764 00:38:10,457 --> 00:38:11,524 not guilty. 765 00:38:14,327 --> 00:38:15,328 Thank you. 766 00:38:20,567 --> 00:38:22,769 - Good luck. - Thanks. 767 00:38:22,902 --> 00:38:24,104 Um, excuse me, everyone. 768 00:38:24,237 --> 00:38:26,720 If... If nobody objects, 769 00:38:26,206 --> 00:38:28,441 I'd really like to throw my name into the ring 770 00:38:28,575 --> 00:38:29,642 to be the forewoman. 771 00:38:29,776 --> 00:38:31,770 I've served on multiple juries. 772 00:38:31,211 --> 00:38:32,545 - I know the ropes. - I'm cool with it. 773 00:38:32,679 --> 00:38:33,913 - Yeah. Sure. - Sure! 774 00:38:34,470 --> 00:38:35,615 - I don't mind. - Okay, great. Thanks. 775 00:38:35,749 --> 00:38:39,252 Okay. So right now we can do one of two things. 776 00:38:39,386 --> 00:38:40,920 We can vote and talk, 777 00:38:41,540 --> 00:38:42,389 or talk and vote. 778 00:38:42,522 --> 00:38:44,570 I suggest that we just vote 779 00:38:44,190 --> 00:38:45,692 and just get an idea where we all stand. 780 00:38:45,825 --> 00:38:47,360 - Does that sound good? - Agreed. 781 00:38:47,494 --> 00:38:50,196 Okay. So I vote "guilty." 782 00:38:50,330 --> 00:38:52,766 Yes, ma'am. Me, too. 783 00:38:52,899 --> 00:38:57,237 Me three. This whole thing is such a shame. 784 00:38:57,370 --> 00:39:00,106 Yeah. I definitely think that he did it. 785 00:39:00,240 --> 00:39:01,241 Definitely. 786 00:39:02,442 --> 00:39:03,443 I agree. 787 00:39:04,577 --> 00:39:05,912 Everything fits together. 788 00:39:06,946 --> 00:39:08,682 Yeah. Let him rot. 789 00:39:10,500 --> 00:39:11,718 [woman 1] Amen. 790 00:39:11,851 --> 00:39:15,422 Nine. So that is nine for guilty. 791 00:39:16,756 --> 00:39:18,558 You, sir? Hi. 792 00:39:18,692 --> 00:39:20,660 Yeah. Oh, yeah. Yeah, guilty's cool. 793 00:39:21,895 --> 00:39:22,896 Okay. 794 00:39:23,530 --> 00:39:24,731 And... 795 00:39:24,864 --> 00:39:26,533 Oh! You, sir? How about you? 796 00:39:26,666 --> 00:39:28,334 Kid should have pled out. 797 00:39:30,670 --> 00:39:32,172 And then there was one. 798 00:39:35,442 --> 00:39:36,976 [Justin sighs] 799 00:39:41,581 --> 00:39:43,616 [somber music playing] 800 00:39:43,750 --> 00:39:46,190 All right. So... what's it gonna be? 801 00:39:46,152 --> 00:39:47,487 You with us or what? 802 00:39:49,155 --> 00:39:50,590 [sighs] 803 00:39:50,724 --> 00:39:52,258 [woman 1 sighs] Tsk. 804 00:39:55,261 --> 00:39:56,863 Don't you want to get home to your pregnant wife? 805 00:39:56,996 --> 00:39:58,198 Of... Of course I do. 806 00:39:58,331 --> 00:39:59,566 All right. So what's the problem? 807 00:40:00,600 --> 00:40:02,135 [stammers] 808 00:40:02,268 --> 00:40:03,470 You know, this is somebody's life we're dealing with. 809 00:40:03,603 --> 00:40:05,805 Shouldn't we at least talk about it? 810 00:40:06,940 --> 00:40:08,541 [sighs] 811 00:40:08,675 --> 00:40:10,844 This is a joke. [sighs] 812 00:40:10,977 --> 00:40:12,946 No, it's, um... Look, it's a deliberation. 813 00:40:13,790 --> 00:40:15,181 You are ready to send this man to prison, 814 00:40:15,315 --> 00:40:16,716 maybe forever, just like that? 815 00:40:16,850 --> 00:40:18,985 [King] And? 816 00:40:19,119 --> 00:40:20,553 I heard the facts of the case. Did you? 817 00:40:20,687 --> 00:40:22,722 Yeah, right. The lawyer didn't prove, 818 00:40:22,856 --> 00:40:25,558 beyond a reasonable doubt, that he was innocent. 819 00:40:25,692 --> 00:40:27,127 Well, he doesn't have to. 820 00:40:27,260 --> 00:40:29,195 The burden of proof is on the prosecution. 821 00:40:29,329 --> 00:40:31,598 Does anyone have even the slightest hesitation 822 00:40:31,731 --> 00:40:33,330 that James Sythe is guilty? 823 00:40:33,166 --> 00:40:36,360 [sighs] I mean... 824 00:40:36,169 --> 00:40:38,171 Look, if you have to think, you aren't sure. 825 00:40:38,304 --> 00:40:39,673 No. 826 00:40:39,806 --> 00:40:41,574 What I'm sure of is, I got three kids at home 827 00:40:41,708 --> 00:40:42,742 I got to get back to. 828 00:40:42,876 --> 00:40:44,244 Look, we all have lives. 829 00:40:44,377 --> 00:40:45,345 None of us want to be here. 830 00:40:45,478 --> 00:40:47,414 Okay. Um, how about we... 831 00:40:47,547 --> 00:40:49,849 Why don't you just tell us what your issue is 832 00:40:49,983 --> 00:40:51,851 or your issues are, 833 00:40:51,985 --> 00:40:53,720 and... and then we can all talk through it? 834 00:40:53,853 --> 00:40:56,756 Oh, I don't have an... an issue. Uh... 835 00:40:56,890 --> 00:40:58,525 Okay. So you just like pissing me off, then? 836 00:40:58,658 --> 00:41:00,593 - Or what? - [scoffs] No. Look, I... 837 00:41:00,727 --> 00:41:02,280 I have questions. 838 00:41:02,162 --> 00:41:04,864 Nah. That's just your guilt talking. 839 00:41:06,199 --> 00:41:07,133 What do you mean? 840 00:41:10,704 --> 00:41:13,206 You want to go home to your little neighborhood 841 00:41:13,340 --> 00:41:14,574 and tell them, 842 00:41:14,708 --> 00:41:16,276 "We did right by that boy. 843 00:41:16,409 --> 00:41:19,612 We gave him a fair shake, just like anybody else." 844 00:41:19,746 --> 00:41:22,820 Whoa, man. Hold up. Why're you getting on him like that? 845 00:41:22,215 --> 00:41:23,249 Hey, mind your own damn business, 846 00:41:23,383 --> 00:41:24,751 all right, little fella? 847 00:41:24,884 --> 00:41:26,920 - Excuse me? - That's enough. Both of you. 848 00:41:29,356 --> 00:41:31,591 Please, Mr. Kemp, go on. 849 00:41:31,725 --> 00:41:32,759 Thank you, ma'am. 850 00:41:34,270 --> 00:41:35,462 All I'm trying to say is, 851 00:41:35,595 --> 00:41:36,963 let's put everything else aside for a minute 852 00:41:37,970 --> 00:41:39,733 and just remember two key points. Um... 853 00:41:39,866 --> 00:41:42,135 One, Sythe went to trial instead of taking a plea, 854 00:41:42,268 --> 00:41:45,238 and two, he testified instead of taking the Fifth. 855 00:41:46,239 --> 00:41:47,741 Right? I mean... 856 00:41:47,874 --> 00:41:49,442 it doesn't mean he's innocent, 857 00:41:49,576 --> 00:41:50,910 but I think he's earned just a few hours of our time 858 00:41:51,440 --> 00:41:52,612 just to be sure. 859 00:41:52,746 --> 00:41:54,981 Uh, he's right. You're right. 860 00:41:55,115 --> 00:41:57,450 We should take the time and we should go over it. 861 00:41:57,584 --> 00:42:00,487 Fine. Fine, but it's a waste of time. 862 00:42:00,620 --> 00:42:02,220 Any other group of 12 people 863 00:42:02,155 --> 00:42:03,590 would arrive at the exact same decision we did. 864 00:42:03,723 --> 00:42:06,292 [woman 1] Mmm-hmm. That part right there. 865 00:42:07,827 --> 00:42:10,797 The State has the truth on its side. 866 00:42:10,930 --> 00:42:13,333 James Sythe is going to pay for what he did. 867 00:42:13,466 --> 00:42:15,668 And I will get justice for Kendall Carter 868 00:42:15,802 --> 00:42:19,439 and every woman who is a victim of domestic abuse. 869 00:42:19,572 --> 00:42:21,241 How do you feel about the latest polling 870 00:42:21,374 --> 00:42:23,760 that a verdict in the Sythe trial 871 00:42:23,209 --> 00:42:24,911 carries a five-point swing in the district attorney race? 872 00:42:25,450 --> 00:42:26,112 Oh, come on. You... 873 00:42:26,246 --> 00:42:28,140 You know I can't comment on that. 874 00:42:28,148 --> 00:42:29,749 Okay. Thank you, everybody. 875 00:42:36,456 --> 00:42:40,894 So I'm just going to start with what I think 876 00:42:41,270 --> 00:42:43,396 is the most damning evidence. 877 00:42:43,530 --> 00:42:46,399 Which was the man who saw 878 00:42:46,533 --> 00:42:49,269 Sythe on the road, at the railing, 879 00:42:49,402 --> 00:42:51,671 directly above where Kendall Carter's body was found. 880 00:42:51,805 --> 00:42:53,340 Yes, exactly. 881 00:42:53,473 --> 00:42:54,974 So what's left to even talk about? 882 00:42:55,108 --> 00:42:56,810 Well, I mean, he was a few hundred feet away, 883 00:42:56,943 --> 00:42:58,111 looking from across the bridge. 884 00:42:58,244 --> 00:43:00,130 And it was the middle of the night, 885 00:43:00,146 --> 00:43:01,848 and through pouring rain. 886 00:43:01,981 --> 00:43:03,249 Yeah. And I've actually done 887 00:43:03,383 --> 00:43:04,684 a bunch of landscaping work up there. 888 00:43:04,818 --> 00:43:06,753 That whole area is covered by trees. 889 00:43:06,886 --> 00:43:08,221 It'd be hard to see. 890 00:43:08,355 --> 00:43:10,590 The man made a positive identification. 891 00:43:10,724 --> 00:43:12,992 Yeah, but dude's kind of ancient, though. 892 00:43:13,126 --> 00:43:14,728 [laughs] 893 00:43:14,861 --> 00:43:18,398 Well, this old bird has 20-20 vision with my glasses. 894 00:43:18,531 --> 00:43:21,134 Come on, y'all. It's his testimony. He's not lying. 895 00:43:21,267 --> 00:43:22,902 I mean, why would he lie? 896 00:43:23,360 --> 00:43:24,571 And the question here means that we think he's lying. 897 00:43:24,704 --> 00:43:26,172 I don't think he's lying. 898 00:43:26,306 --> 00:43:27,307 You think he's lying? 899 00:43:27,440 --> 00:43:29,900 No, I don't think he's lying-- 900 00:43:29,142 --> 00:43:30,143 [woman 1] Okay. So what the hell are we talking about? 901 00:43:30,276 --> 00:43:31,678 Look, I'm just saying... Okay. 902 00:43:31,811 --> 00:43:33,680 The man, he saw somebody at the railing, right? 903 00:43:33,813 --> 00:43:34,881 Can we all agree on that? 904 00:43:35,150 --> 00:43:35,915 - Yeah. - Yes. 905 00:43:36,490 --> 00:43:37,684 Okay. So isn't it possible 906 00:43:37,817 --> 00:43:39,719 - that he saw someone other than James Sythe? - Oh! 907 00:43:39,853 --> 00:43:42,222 Mmm-mmm. No, we can go back and forth all day on possibilities. 908 00:43:42,355 --> 00:43:43,690 That's not helpful. 909 00:43:43,823 --> 00:43:44,591 - Well, I think we should. - No, no, no. 910 00:43:44,724 --> 00:43:45,892 No. That's not our job. 911 00:43:46,260 --> 00:43:47,560 Our job is to just weigh the facts. 912 00:43:48,762 --> 00:43:50,830 [sighs] Okay. Fact. 913 00:43:50,964 --> 00:43:54,334 32% of homicides occur between domestic partners. 914 00:43:54,467 --> 00:43:56,236 Fact, the police arrested James Sythe 915 00:43:56,369 --> 00:43:58,380 two days after they found the body. 916 00:43:58,171 --> 00:44:01,207 Fact, they never questioned any other suspects. 917 00:44:01,341 --> 00:44:03,176 You watch too much TV, old man. [scoffs] 918 00:44:03,309 --> 00:44:04,711 [chuckles] 919 00:44:04,844 --> 00:44:07,213 [sighs] Okay. 920 00:44:13,253 --> 00:44:14,421 You're a cop? 921 00:44:16,189 --> 00:44:17,557 I was. 922 00:44:17,691 --> 00:44:19,759 Twenty-two years. Robbery-homicide. 923 00:44:21,661 --> 00:44:23,797 Finally took the buyout, came down here to get away 924 00:44:23,930 --> 00:44:25,899 from those brutal Midwest winters 925 00:44:26,320 --> 00:44:27,600 and be closer to the grandkids. 926 00:44:27,734 --> 00:44:29,602 Why didn't you... Why didn't you tell the lawyers? 927 00:44:29,736 --> 00:44:31,104 'Cause nobody asked. 928 00:44:31,237 --> 00:44:33,106 How about that. 929 00:44:33,239 --> 00:44:35,575 Well, their loss is our gain. 930 00:44:35,709 --> 00:44:37,577 So what are you thinking, officer? 931 00:44:37,711 --> 00:44:39,120 Uh, Detective. 932 00:44:39,145 --> 00:44:40,180 Um... 933 00:44:40,313 --> 00:44:41,848 Look, I think... 934 00:44:41,981 --> 00:44:43,516 It seems to me like the police, 935 00:44:43,650 --> 00:44:45,850 you know, followed the evidence, 936 00:44:45,218 --> 00:44:46,986 found their guy, built their case. 937 00:44:47,120 --> 00:44:49,890 Okay. So what's wrong with that? 938 00:44:49,222 --> 00:44:51,157 It may be nothing, but tunnel vision like that 939 00:44:51,291 --> 00:44:53,590 can really bite you in the ***. 940 00:44:53,193 --> 00:44:55,228 They feed Sythe to that eyewitness, 941 00:44:55,362 --> 00:44:57,464 so, of course, that's who he IDs. 942 00:44:57,597 --> 00:44:59,332 Now they're sure they got their guy, 943 00:44:59,466 --> 00:45:01,735 so they just ignore anything that doesn't help their case. 944 00:45:01,868 --> 00:45:04,404 They stop asking questions. 945 00:45:04,537 --> 00:45:05,905 Confirmation bias. 946 00:45:06,390 --> 00:45:07,874 Yeah, confirmation bias. Exactly. 947 00:45:08,800 --> 00:45:09,420 Confirmation bias. 948 00:45:09,175 --> 00:45:10,944 There's no bad intentions. 949 00:45:11,770 --> 00:45:13,680 It's just a bunch of people trying to do the right thing, 950 00:45:13,813 --> 00:45:17,170 and they can't see everything they're doing wrong. 951 00:45:17,150 --> 00:45:19,386 It's a good point. 952 00:45:19,519 --> 00:45:22,989 And what about this blunt instrument murder weapon 953 00:45:23,123 --> 00:45:24,624 they kept talking about? 954 00:45:24,758 --> 00:45:27,360 The prosecutor said they couldn't recover it. 955 00:45:27,494 --> 00:45:29,662 So he got rid of it. That's easy to do. 956 00:45:29,796 --> 00:45:31,164 Or he could have killed her 957 00:45:31,297 --> 00:45:33,933 with something other than a blunt instrument. 958 00:45:34,670 --> 00:45:35,101 Like what? 959 00:45:36,636 --> 00:45:38,872 Like a car? 960 00:45:39,500 --> 00:45:40,340 It could have been a hit-and-run. 961 00:45:42,442 --> 00:45:43,743 [Justin] Oh, shit. 962 00:45:43,877 --> 00:45:45,145 - Here. Let me help. - I'm sorry. Sorry. 963 00:45:45,278 --> 00:45:46,460 - It got in your pants. - It's all right. 964 00:45:46,179 --> 00:45:47,414 You know, that's... 965 00:45:47,547 --> 00:45:49,649 That's a really, really good theory. 966 00:45:49,783 --> 00:45:51,418 - Hit-and-run. - [Robinson] Yeah. 967 00:45:51,551 --> 00:45:52,752 I mean, it's raining, it's night. 968 00:45:52,886 --> 00:45:54,654 Visibility's got to be terrible. 969 00:45:54,788 --> 00:45:57,357 Well, we know it was slippery, from that hiker's testimony. 970 00:45:57,490 --> 00:46:00,193 Wandering around in the dark in heels? 971 00:46:00,326 --> 00:46:02,529 Kids today... 972 00:46:02,662 --> 00:46:06,800 Um, it explains how she could have ended up in a creek. 973 00:46:06,933 --> 00:46:08,735 [jurors] Mmm-hmm. 974 00:46:08,868 --> 00:46:12,105 Okay. So, Sythe mowed her down instead of bashing her head in? 975 00:46:12,238 --> 00:46:13,573 What are we talking about here? 976 00:46:13,707 --> 00:46:14,874 What difference does it make? 977 00:46:15,800 --> 00:46:17,410 The guy is a piece of shit. 978 00:46:17,544 --> 00:46:21,715 Look, my gut is telling me that that kid is not a killer. 979 00:46:21,848 --> 00:46:24,250 - Okay. The other day, you voted guilty. - [woman] Mmm-hmm. 980 00:46:24,384 --> 00:46:26,219 No. No, I never said guilty. 981 00:46:26,353 --> 00:46:29,222 I said, he should have taken a plea bargain. 982 00:46:29,356 --> 00:46:30,990 He's got a weak case. 983 00:46:31,124 --> 00:46:32,859 [woman] Well, maybe there's a reason for that. 984 00:46:32,992 --> 00:46:35,695 [Chicowski] Yeah. It's called a public defender. 985 00:46:35,829 --> 00:46:36,930 I mean, nothing against this guy. 986 00:46:37,630 --> 00:46:38,331 He seems pretty smart, 987 00:46:38,465 --> 00:46:41,201 but... the PDs are working 10 times 988 00:46:41,334 --> 00:46:44,771 the caseload of the DA's office on a fraction of the budget. 989 00:46:44,904 --> 00:46:46,406 It's just not a fair fight. 990 00:46:46,539 --> 00:46:48,875 Yeah, well, nothing is anymore. 991 00:46:49,900 --> 00:46:50,577 We'll just do the best we can. 992 00:46:50,710 --> 00:46:51,711 I hear you. 993 00:46:53,380 --> 00:46:55,382 And I got 22 years on the street, 994 00:46:55,515 --> 00:46:57,250 that is telling me 995 00:46:57,384 --> 00:46:59,953 there's a lot more to this case than we know. 996 00:47:00,860 --> 00:47:02,589 All right. Then, if you were still a detective, 997 00:47:02,722 --> 00:47:03,757 what would you do? 998 00:47:03,890 --> 00:47:05,959 Yeah. 999 00:47:06,920 --> 00:47:08,728 All right, y'all. That's it for today. 1000 00:47:08,862 --> 00:47:12,766 See you back here at 9:00 a.m. Monday morning. 1001 00:47:12,899 --> 00:47:15,235 Oh! And I almost forgot. Happy Halloween. 1002 00:47:15,368 --> 00:47:17,137 [jurors] Happy Halloween! 1003 00:47:19,439 --> 00:47:20,407 Hey! 1004 00:47:20,540 --> 00:47:22,475 Yeah, it has been a minute. 1005 00:47:22,609 --> 00:47:24,744 But I was hoping you could do me a solid. 1006 00:47:25,879 --> 00:47:26,846 Hang on a sec. 1007 00:47:29,282 --> 00:47:30,784 [engine starts] 1008 00:47:32,218 --> 00:47:33,386 Yeah, I'm here. 1009 00:47:34,688 --> 00:47:36,560 [car engine starts] 1010 00:47:43,563 --> 00:47:45,432 [keyboard clacking] 1011 00:47:50,770 --> 00:47:52,205 "We cannot break the law. 1012 00:47:52,339 --> 00:47:55,108 "We can only break ourselves of the law." 1013 00:47:56,976 --> 00:47:58,110 [knock at door] 1014 00:47:59,790 --> 00:48:00,246 - No decision yet. - [sighs] 1015 00:48:00,380 --> 00:48:01,648 We're breaking for the weekend. 1016 00:48:01,781 --> 00:48:03,350 You're kidding. 1017 00:48:03,483 --> 00:48:05,185 You never know what a dozen strangers are gonna do. 1018 00:48:05,318 --> 00:48:07,253 Clearly. Okay. Well, thanks for letting me know. 1019 00:48:07,387 --> 00:48:08,655 - See you Monday. - Mmm-hmm. 1020 00:48:08,788 --> 00:48:10,690 - Trick or treat! - Yeah. Have a good one. 1021 00:48:10,824 --> 00:48:12,325 [keyboard clacking] 1022 00:48:12,459 --> 00:48:13,593 [sighs] 1023 00:48:53,566 --> 00:48:56,169 [somber music playing] 1024 00:48:59,639 --> 00:49:01,410 [cell phone rings] 1025 00:49:11,518 --> 00:49:13,186 [cell phone rings] 1026 00:49:16,489 --> 00:49:17,924 Hey, hon. 1027 00:49:18,580 --> 00:49:21,940 Yeah, I'm heading back to the shop right now. 1028 00:49:21,928 --> 00:49:22,929 Okay. 1029 00:49:26,866 --> 00:49:28,702 [engine starts] 1030 00:49:53,590 --> 00:49:54,661 Hey. 1031 00:49:54,794 --> 00:49:56,596 - Hi. - Did you get my text? 1032 00:49:59,990 --> 00:50:00,266 Oh, shit. 1033 00:50:00,400 --> 00:50:01,601 Sorry. 1034 00:50:02,602 --> 00:50:04,270 I'm sorry, I forgot. 1035 00:50:05,238 --> 00:50:06,539 Does everything look okay? 1036 00:50:08,942 --> 00:50:09,943 Are you okay? 1037 00:50:16,282 --> 00:50:17,917 Hey, hey, hey, what's wrong? 1038 00:50:18,510 --> 00:50:19,520 I'm scared. 1039 00:50:21,540 --> 00:50:23,623 I'm scared. We didn't make it this far last time, and... 1040 00:50:24,290 --> 00:50:25,258 I'm just scared. 1041 00:50:27,600 --> 00:50:28,428 I don't want to be doing this alone. 1042 00:50:28,561 --> 00:50:29,996 I don't want to go to these things alone. 1043 00:50:31,297 --> 00:50:32,866 It's going to be okay. 1044 00:50:32,999 --> 00:50:34,434 [stammers] It's going to be all right, I promise. 1045 00:50:34,567 --> 00:50:35,402 I don't understand why you weren't there today. 1046 00:50:38,938 --> 00:50:41,775 How much longer is the trial going to go on for? 1047 00:50:41,908 --> 00:50:44,911 [sighs] I have no idea. 1048 00:50:45,450 --> 00:50:47,180 - It's... - Are you close to a verdict? 1049 00:50:47,313 --> 00:50:48,815 I'm not supposed to discuss the case-- 1050 00:50:48,948 --> 00:50:50,617 Justin, are you close to a verdict? 1051 00:50:50,750 --> 00:50:53,653 Well, it's ten to two for guilty. 1052 00:50:55,755 --> 00:50:57,190 So then, Monday, 1053 00:50:57,323 --> 00:50:59,125 can you just go in and sway the two holdouts 1054 00:50:59,259 --> 00:51:00,960 and then be done with this? 1055 00:51:01,940 --> 00:51:03,997 Well, I'm one of them. I... 1056 00:51:05,799 --> 00:51:07,600 - Why? - I'm sorry, 1057 00:51:07,734 --> 00:51:09,350 but they took one look at this guy, and that was it. 1058 00:51:09,169 --> 00:51:10,937 No discussion of the evidence, nothing. 1059 00:51:11,710 --> 00:51:12,105 I had to do something. 1060 00:51:15,342 --> 00:51:16,943 Everyone deserves a chance, right? 1061 00:51:18,778 --> 00:51:21,147 I keep thinking where I'd be if you hadn't given me one. 1062 00:51:26,653 --> 00:51:28,355 [stammers] Can I ask you something? 1063 00:51:28,488 --> 00:51:30,190 [sighs] 1064 00:51:30,323 --> 00:51:32,859 Yeah, sure. What? 1065 00:51:32,992 --> 00:51:35,161 If I were to sell the 4Runner without telling someone 1066 00:51:35,295 --> 00:51:37,300 it was in a wreck, 1067 00:51:37,163 --> 00:51:38,832 but they're happy with the deal and there's no safety risks. 1068 00:51:38,965 --> 00:51:40,800 - It was in the ad, Justin. - I know, I know, 1069 00:51:40,934 --> 00:51:42,135 but just go with me. 1070 00:51:42,268 --> 00:51:44,204 If they're never the wiser, 1071 00:51:44,337 --> 00:51:46,473 then did I do anything wrong? 1072 00:51:47,400 --> 00:51:48,800 No. 1073 00:51:49,175 --> 00:51:50,543 I mean, I don't think so. 1074 00:51:52,145 --> 00:51:53,146 Yeah. 1075 00:51:55,815 --> 00:51:56,916 I'm going upstairs. 1076 00:51:57,500 --> 00:51:59,190 [melancholy music playing] 1077 00:51:59,986 --> 00:52:01,221 Food's in the fridge. 1078 00:52:01,354 --> 00:52:02,622 See you upstairs. 1079 00:52:09,396 --> 00:52:10,530 [sighs] 1080 00:52:29,115 --> 00:52:31,818 There she is. Next round's on her. 1081 00:52:31,951 --> 00:52:33,887 Bourbon. Neat. And... 1082 00:52:34,200 --> 00:52:35,288 yeah, whatever he's having. 1083 00:52:35,422 --> 00:52:38,825 What I'm having? What I'm having is a... 1084 00:52:38,958 --> 00:52:40,930 - Thank you. - ...great evening. 1085 00:52:40,226 --> 00:52:41,695 Isn't it a beautiful evening? 1086 00:52:41,828 --> 00:52:43,763 It should have been a two-hour verdict. 1087 00:52:43,897 --> 00:52:46,320 What can I tell you? They're taking their job seriously. 1088 00:52:46,166 --> 00:52:47,567 I gave them a lot to think about. 1089 00:52:47,701 --> 00:52:50,700 Mmm. I got a mountain of evidence. 1090 00:52:50,203 --> 00:52:51,805 You gave them smoke and mirrors. 1091 00:52:51,938 --> 00:52:53,406 Where there's smoke, there's fire. 1092 00:52:53,540 --> 00:52:57,444 [laughs] I admire your optimism. 1093 00:52:57,577 --> 00:52:59,145 Look, here's the thing. You walk into court 1094 00:52:59,279 --> 00:53:02,982 convinced of the guilt of the defendant. Me, I... 1095 00:53:03,116 --> 00:53:04,517 I have no illusions about what I do. 1096 00:53:04,651 --> 00:53:06,319 A lot of my clients are guilty, 1097 00:53:06,453 --> 00:53:09,289 and my job is to help make the best of a bad situation. 1098 00:53:09,422 --> 00:53:11,324 But I'm telling you... 1099 00:53:11,458 --> 00:53:13,426 I'm telling you, this guy didn't do it. 1100 00:53:16,396 --> 00:53:19,799 And the fact that the jury's taking a little time 1101 00:53:19,933 --> 00:53:21,468 gives me hope that things are working 1102 00:53:21,601 --> 00:53:22,836 the way they should. 1103 00:53:24,404 --> 00:53:28,274 Well... you enjoy that while it lasts. 1104 00:53:31,444 --> 00:53:34,314 To the justice system. 1105 00:53:34,447 --> 00:53:37,450 It ain't perfect, but it's the best we got. 1106 00:53:47,927 --> 00:53:49,262 - Hey. - Hey. 1107 00:53:49,396 --> 00:53:51,197 I'm sorry again about yesterday. 1108 00:53:51,331 --> 00:53:52,799 It's just that case wearing on me. 1109 00:53:53,833 --> 00:53:55,350 I know. I can tell. 1110 00:53:55,168 --> 00:53:56,970 - Yeah. - Trust your gut. 1111 00:53:57,103 --> 00:53:58,538 You'll do the right thing. 1112 00:53:58,672 --> 00:54:00,730 - [doorbell rings] - Oh! Oh, Oh, wait. 1113 00:54:00,206 --> 00:54:01,408 - [kids laughing] - Wait, wait, wait. 1114 00:54:05,645 --> 00:54:07,580 - What's that? - It's my pitchfork. 1115 00:54:07,714 --> 00:54:09,349 - Nice! - Yeah. Thanks. 1116 00:54:09,482 --> 00:54:10,750 - [laughs] - Homemade. 1117 00:54:13,453 --> 00:54:15,722 - [kids] Trick or treat! - Hey! Happy Halloween! 1118 00:54:15,855 --> 00:54:18,458 I love your costumes! Take two, everyone. 1119 00:54:20,593 --> 00:54:21,494 Oliver? 1120 00:54:21,628 --> 00:54:23,229 Hey, Ms. Crewson. 1121 00:54:23,363 --> 00:54:26,166 Oliver, I didn't even recognize you! How are you? 1122 00:54:26,299 --> 00:54:27,734 I'm good. Hi, Mr. Kemp. 1123 00:54:27,867 --> 00:54:29,369 Hey, how's the writing going? 1124 00:54:29,502 --> 00:54:31,204 - I'm on student paper now. - No way. That's awesome. 1125 00:54:31,338 --> 00:54:32,706 - That's very cool. - Congrats. 1126 00:54:32,839 --> 00:54:34,341 - Hey, have fun tonight. - [Oliver] We will. 1127 00:54:34,474 --> 00:54:35,608 See you back at school? 1128 00:54:35,742 --> 00:54:37,177 - Yeah. Next year. - [Oliver] Okay. 1129 00:54:37,310 --> 00:54:38,611 Well, bye. 1130 00:54:38,745 --> 00:54:40,347 - Bye! - Keep it up! 1131 00:54:40,480 --> 00:54:42,449 - God, he's a giant. - I know. 1132 00:54:42,582 --> 00:54:44,500 Happy Halloween. 1133 00:54:49,189 --> 00:54:50,190 Thanks. 1134 00:55:02,602 --> 00:55:04,700 - Hey. - Hey. 1135 00:55:04,204 --> 00:55:06,906 Why'd you follow me after court on Friday? 1136 00:55:07,400 --> 00:55:09,109 I picked your tail up, like, halfway out of the parking lot. 1137 00:55:09,242 --> 00:55:11,911 I mean, green Toyota 4Runner, right? 1138 00:55:12,450 --> 00:55:14,470 Uh, yeah, well, you're... 1139 00:55:14,180 --> 00:55:15,448 you're not allowed to investigate the case 1140 00:55:15,582 --> 00:55:16,783 outside the jury room. 1141 00:55:17,751 --> 00:55:19,786 Yeah. Yeah, I know. 1142 00:55:19,919 --> 00:55:23,390 But... I mean, somebody's got to. 1143 00:55:23,523 --> 00:55:24,891 Don't you want to know what really happened? 1144 00:55:25,250 --> 00:55:26,726 Yeah. Of course. 1145 00:55:27,660 --> 00:55:29,295 Look, I, uh... 1146 00:55:29,429 --> 00:55:30,397 I did some digging. 1147 00:55:32,465 --> 00:55:34,267 This is every registered car in the county 1148 00:55:34,401 --> 00:55:35,902 that was in for body work 1149 00:55:36,360 --> 00:55:37,604 between October 26th and the end of last year. 1150 00:55:37,737 --> 00:55:39,172 You're still about the hit-and-run? Come on, it's-- 1151 00:55:39,305 --> 00:55:41,740 Yeah, because that's a really good theory. 1152 00:55:41,207 --> 00:55:43,843 Now, the automakers keep a detailed list 1153 00:55:43,977 --> 00:55:46,880 of these repairs strictly for R and D purposes. 1154 00:55:47,130 --> 00:55:49,315 They collect it from the dealers pro forma 1155 00:55:49,449 --> 00:55:51,618 and then pay the mom-and-pop shops under the table. 1156 00:55:51,751 --> 00:55:53,530 My partner and I recovered more cars 1157 00:55:53,186 --> 00:55:54,654 than an impound this way. 1158 00:55:54,788 --> 00:55:57,570 Right. But there must be hundreds of cars in there. 1159 00:55:57,190 --> 00:55:59,590 Yeah, so process of elimination, 1160 00:55:59,192 --> 00:56:01,895 which is what I spent my whole weekend doing. 1161 00:56:02,280 --> 00:56:04,431 I mean, anything there's already a police report for, 1162 00:56:04,564 --> 00:56:05,498 crossed off the list. 1163 00:56:05,632 --> 00:56:07,367 Mmm. 1164 00:56:07,500 --> 00:56:08,935 And there's only going to be a very specific kind of damage 1165 00:56:09,690 --> 00:56:10,360 with this kind of hit-and-run. 1166 00:56:10,170 --> 00:56:13,273 So a headlight, grille, hood. 1167 00:56:13,406 --> 00:56:15,875 - Yeah. - I narrowed it down to 15 vehicles 1168 00:56:16,900 --> 00:56:17,977 that match that description on this list, 1169 00:56:18,111 --> 00:56:19,446 one of which, by the way, 1170 00:56:19,579 --> 00:56:22,582 a '96 Toyota 4Runner, Forest Green. 1171 00:56:22,716 --> 00:56:25,318 I mean, that's the exact same car as yours, right? 1172 00:56:25,452 --> 00:56:26,686 I mean, if that is your car, 1173 00:56:26,820 --> 00:56:28,822 we can just cross it off the list. 1174 00:56:28,955 --> 00:56:32,258 Right. Yeah. So what's the plan? 1175 00:56:32,392 --> 00:56:34,461 Well, if you don't mind helping, 1176 00:56:34,594 --> 00:56:36,290 there's only so many hours in the day, 1177 00:56:36,162 --> 00:56:37,530 and we got to spend most of them here. 1178 00:56:37,664 --> 00:56:38,898 So you want to help me with the legwork, 1179 00:56:39,320 --> 00:56:40,500 and see if we can find our guy. 1180 00:56:40,633 --> 00:56:43,690 Yeah. Okay. You know, you're reaching, but... 1181 00:56:43,203 --> 00:56:44,637 Look, I... It's a hit-and-run, kid. 1182 00:56:44,771 --> 00:56:46,172 I feel it in my bones. 1183 00:56:46,306 --> 00:56:48,375 Dollars to doughnuts, our guy is on this list. 1184 00:56:48,508 --> 00:56:52,278 [bailiff] Oh, good morning. Party time, y'all, let's go. 1185 00:56:54,814 --> 00:56:56,216 Fellas, wrap it up. 1186 00:56:56,349 --> 00:56:57,550 Thanks. 1187 00:57:00,420 --> 00:57:01,454 [bailiff] Let's go. 1188 00:57:03,823 --> 00:57:04,758 God damn it! 1189 00:57:04,891 --> 00:57:06,926 [grunts] Hmm. 1190 00:57:07,600 --> 00:57:08,495 Everything all right over here? 1191 00:57:08,628 --> 00:57:09,929 [Justin] Mmm? 1192 00:57:10,630 --> 00:57:11,264 [bailiff] Y'all working my nerve today. 1193 00:57:13,133 --> 00:57:14,367 What is all this? 1194 00:57:19,139 --> 00:57:21,374 Just... You two, wait for me. 1195 00:57:23,710 --> 00:57:26,913 Read instruction 0.01 for me, please. 1196 00:57:30,950 --> 00:57:32,419 Uh... 1197 00:57:32,552 --> 00:57:33,887 "To maintain the integrity of the jury system, 1198 00:57:34,200 --> 00:57:35,855 I remind you that you must decide this case 1199 00:57:35,989 --> 00:57:38,240 based only on the evidence admitted during the trial 1200 00:57:38,158 --> 00:57:40,126 and the law I will explain to you. 1201 00:57:40,260 --> 00:57:41,795 You may not conduct any research 1202 00:57:41,928 --> 00:57:43,697 on your own about this case 1203 00:57:43,830 --> 00:57:46,466 or about any people or places mentioned during the trial." 1204 00:57:46,599 --> 00:57:48,201 Sounds to me like you two violated 1205 00:57:48,334 --> 00:57:49,903 every sentence of that paragraph. 1206 00:57:50,360 --> 00:57:51,304 Your Honor, I move for a mistrial. 1207 00:57:51,438 --> 00:57:53,600 He's a former cop. 1208 00:57:53,139 --> 00:57:54,607 Who knows what ideas he put in the jury's heads. 1209 00:57:54,741 --> 00:57:56,543 Failure to elicit his previous employment 1210 00:57:56,676 --> 00:57:59,546 during voir dire is on you, Mr. Resnick. 1211 00:57:59,679 --> 00:58:01,247 [Eric] It's misconduct. 1212 00:58:01,381 --> 00:58:02,949 Kick him off, Judge. There's no need to start over. 1213 00:58:03,830 --> 00:58:05,452 Our resources are already stretched so thin. 1214 00:58:08,521 --> 00:58:10,323 She's right. Motion denied. 1215 00:58:10,457 --> 00:58:11,891 Your Honor. You know... 1216 00:58:12,692 --> 00:58:13,960 As for you two... 1217 00:58:16,629 --> 00:58:18,398 You violated your oath as jurors. 1218 00:58:21,670 --> 00:58:22,569 Your Honor... 1219 00:58:22,702 --> 00:58:24,104 if I may. I, uh... 1220 00:58:24,237 --> 00:58:26,639 I upheld the oath I took as a police officer 1221 00:58:26,773 --> 00:58:28,742 to never betray my character, 1222 00:58:28,875 --> 00:58:31,277 my integrity, or the public trust. 1223 00:58:36,850 --> 00:58:38,952 Mr. Chicowski, [sighs] 1224 00:58:39,850 --> 00:58:41,187 you are hereby removed from Jury Service. 1225 00:58:43,123 --> 00:58:44,124 On account of your background, 1226 00:58:44,257 --> 00:58:45,592 I'm going to make an exception 1227 00:58:45,725 --> 00:58:48,328 and not find you in contempt of court. 1228 00:58:49,662 --> 00:58:50,964 Thank you, Your Honor. 1229 00:58:52,432 --> 00:58:54,100 So Mr. Kemp, 1230 00:58:54,234 --> 00:58:56,302 you are not a retired law enforcement officer, are you? 1231 00:58:56,436 --> 00:58:58,138 No. No, Your Honor. 1232 00:58:58,271 --> 00:58:59,639 So how do you explain 1233 00:58:59,773 --> 00:59:03,576 your involvement in this transgression? 1234 00:59:03,710 --> 00:59:06,279 I obtained those documents on my own, Your Honor. 1235 00:59:06,413 --> 00:59:08,314 He didn't have anything to do with it. 1236 00:59:09,449 --> 00:59:10,650 Is that true? 1237 00:59:10,784 --> 00:59:12,118 Mmm. 1238 00:59:12,252 --> 00:59:13,820 I mean, did you look at these documents 1239 00:59:13,953 --> 00:59:15,555 or help to procure them 1240 00:59:15,689 --> 00:59:18,158 or know what Mr. Chicowski was intending to do? 1241 00:59:18,291 --> 00:59:20,627 No, Your Honor. I did not look at them 1242 00:59:20,760 --> 00:59:21,895 and I didn't help. 1243 00:59:24,300 --> 00:59:26,166 So do you think that you can disregard 1244 00:59:26,299 --> 00:59:28,134 everything that you heard just now 1245 00:59:28,268 --> 00:59:30,670 and remain an unbiased member of this panel? 1246 00:59:30,804 --> 00:59:32,105 Yes, I can. 1247 00:59:33,807 --> 00:59:36,109 I'm going to take you at your word. 1248 00:59:36,242 --> 00:59:39,779 Bailiff, please escort Mr. Kemp back to the juror room. 1249 00:59:41,381 --> 00:59:45,352 Mr. Chicowski, you are dismissed. 1250 00:59:45,485 --> 00:59:47,387 Your Honor, I would ask that a copy of these documents 1251 00:59:47,520 --> 00:59:48,922 be made part of the court's records 1252 00:59:49,550 --> 00:59:50,256 for purposes of appeal. 1253 00:59:50,390 --> 00:59:52,559 And again, I move for a mistrial. 1254 00:59:52,692 --> 00:59:55,829 The documents will be marked as court's Exhibit One. 1255 00:59:55,962 --> 01:00:00,660 Your motion for a mistrial is denied, Mr. Resnick. 1256 01:00:00,200 --> 01:00:02,669 Is that understood? 1257 01:00:02,802 --> 01:00:05,472 Yes, Your Honor. It's understood. 1258 01:00:05,605 --> 01:00:08,141 Good. Then we are done here. 1259 01:00:16,549 --> 01:00:18,385 - You got to be kidding me. - What? 1260 01:00:18,518 --> 01:00:20,553 "Our resources are stretched so thin"? 1261 01:00:21,588 --> 01:00:22,689 You are something. 1262 01:00:26,526 --> 01:00:27,527 Okay. 1263 01:00:29,662 --> 01:00:30,697 [sighs] 1264 01:00:34,667 --> 01:00:36,690 Counselor. 1265 01:00:36,202 --> 01:00:37,270 Hey, it's okay. I'm not on the jury anymore. 1266 01:00:37,404 --> 01:00:38,538 - You don't have to... - Yeah. 1267 01:00:38,672 --> 01:00:40,173 Yeah, made sure of that. 1268 01:00:40,974 --> 01:00:42,800 [sighs] 1269 01:00:43,176 --> 01:00:44,377 Feeling the pressure, huh? 1270 01:00:45,278 --> 01:00:47,647 In this job? Nah. 1271 01:00:47,781 --> 01:00:50,817 - [both chuckle] - Yeah. Okay. 1272 01:00:58,458 --> 01:00:59,926 Hey, I'm... Sorry, but I just... 1273 01:01:00,600 --> 01:01:02,620 I can't not say this. You... 1274 01:01:03,697 --> 01:01:06,990 [sighs] You got this case all wrong. 1275 01:01:07,167 --> 01:01:09,350 - Oh, really? - Yeah. 1276 01:01:09,169 --> 01:01:10,303 It's a hit-and-run. 1277 01:01:10,437 --> 01:01:12,706 No way. ME would have flagged it. 1278 01:01:12,839 --> 01:01:15,800 Well, yeah, you'd think. 1279 01:01:15,141 --> 01:01:17,410 That guy did five autopsies that day. 1280 01:01:17,544 --> 01:01:19,646 One day. I checked. 1281 01:01:19,779 --> 01:01:21,147 Doesn't mean anything. 1282 01:01:26,520 --> 01:01:28,288 Let me just ask you one thing. 1283 01:01:28,421 --> 01:01:30,657 Did you guys ever look at any other suspect? 1284 01:01:32,692 --> 01:01:34,894 We did our job. 1285 01:01:35,280 --> 01:01:36,963 All due respect, Counselor, if you'd have done your job, 1286 01:01:37,970 --> 01:01:38,631 I don't think we'd be standing here right now. 1287 01:01:38,765 --> 01:01:40,667 Well, that guy is bad news. 1288 01:01:43,103 --> 01:01:44,104 Maybe. 1289 01:01:46,473 --> 01:01:47,941 But he didn't kill that girl. 1290 01:01:51,311 --> 01:01:53,146 [pensive music playing] 1291 01:02:04,891 --> 01:02:06,192 [bailiff] All right. So with that being said, 1292 01:02:06,326 --> 01:02:08,528 Judge Stewart thanks you for your patience 1293 01:02:08,661 --> 01:02:11,197 and apologizes for any inconvenience. 1294 01:02:11,331 --> 01:02:14,667 Juror number 13 is now a voting member of this panel. 1295 01:02:15,301 --> 01:02:16,469 Okay. 1296 01:02:16,603 --> 01:02:18,371 I'll let you guys get back to it. 1297 01:02:22,420 --> 01:02:23,810 So what happened? 1298 01:02:23,943 --> 01:02:26,790 What was this misconduct? 1299 01:02:26,212 --> 01:02:28,140 Uh, that's between him and the judge. 1300 01:02:28,148 --> 01:02:30,316 Bullshit. You were there. 1301 01:02:30,450 --> 01:02:31,751 What did Harold do? 1302 01:02:33,319 --> 01:02:36,456 He was investigating the case on his own. 1303 01:02:36,589 --> 01:02:37,624 The judge sent him home. 1304 01:02:39,250 --> 01:02:40,527 What about that stack of papers? 1305 01:02:40,660 --> 01:02:41,661 What papers? 1306 01:02:41,795 --> 01:02:43,463 The ones Harold gave to him. 1307 01:02:43,596 --> 01:02:45,331 You dropped them all over the floor. We all saw it. 1308 01:02:45,465 --> 01:02:48,568 The bailiff was on us before I looked at the papers, so... 1309 01:02:48,702 --> 01:02:50,670 You were talking for quite a while. 1310 01:02:50,804 --> 01:02:52,672 Did he tell you what was in them? 1311 01:02:54,674 --> 01:02:56,509 Okay, yes, he did. It... 1312 01:02:56,643 --> 01:02:59,612 It was a printout. Names, vehicle registrations... 1313 01:02:59,746 --> 01:03:02,382 He said that it could prove 1314 01:03:02,515 --> 01:03:03,516 James Sythe's innocence. 1315 01:03:03,650 --> 01:03:05,652 - [all murmuring] - So what? 1316 01:03:05,785 --> 01:03:06,986 Are we just supposed to believe you now 1317 01:03:07,120 --> 01:03:08,321 and change our vote? 1318 01:03:08,455 --> 01:03:09,556 No, I'm just telling you what I know. 1319 01:03:11,658 --> 01:03:13,326 He thinks it was a hit-and-run. 1320 01:03:45,925 --> 01:03:49,290 So if he thinks it was a hit-and-run... 1321 01:03:53,466 --> 01:03:55,168 Kendall was 5'5". 1322 01:03:56,360 --> 01:03:59,272 If she was hunched over, 1323 01:03:59,406 --> 01:04:02,509 and the car was an SUV or a truck, 1324 01:04:02,642 --> 01:04:04,177 she could have easily have been hit 1325 01:04:04,310 --> 01:04:06,146 smack across the head and torso. 1326 01:04:08,581 --> 01:04:11,117 Look at the way her shoulders are fractured. 1327 01:04:11,251 --> 01:04:13,386 Well, I'm sorry, but are you a doctor? 1328 01:04:14,721 --> 01:04:17,424 Not yet. Third-year med student. 1329 01:04:17,557 --> 01:04:19,920 I... I mean, 1330 01:04:19,225 --> 01:04:20,894 I think we should leave that to the professionals, 1331 01:04:21,270 --> 01:04:22,796 the medical examiner who, you know, examined the body. 1332 01:04:22,929 --> 01:04:25,598 Well, I mean, doctors can be careless. 1333 01:04:25,732 --> 01:04:27,834 One time they told my dad he was having a heart attack. 1334 01:04:27,967 --> 01:04:29,869 Turned out it was just gas. 1335 01:04:30,300 --> 01:04:32,539 [chuckles] They're always in such a rush. 1336 01:04:32,672 --> 01:04:34,541 Go ahead, dear. Speak your mind. 1337 01:04:38,611 --> 01:04:42,349 The right and left clavicle both show a very clean break. 1338 01:04:42,482 --> 01:04:43,817 Can you pass this around? 1339 01:04:45,652 --> 01:04:47,200 She couldn't get that from the fall? 1340 01:04:48,540 --> 01:04:49,689 It's not likely. 1341 01:04:49,823 --> 01:04:54,494 Both bones had to be broken by a single, 1342 01:04:54,627 --> 01:04:57,130 sharp, posterior impact. 1343 01:04:58,698 --> 01:05:00,567 Pow. 1344 01:05:00,700 --> 01:05:03,670 Do we know if Sythe's car had any damage? 1345 01:05:05,338 --> 01:05:06,639 No. The police would have noted it 1346 01:05:06,773 --> 01:05:08,108 in their report if it did. 1347 01:05:08,241 --> 01:05:09,542 Not if they thought it was irrelevant. 1348 01:05:09,676 --> 01:05:11,711 [scoffs] Cops hate paperwork. 1349 01:05:11,845 --> 01:05:13,546 So you're some kind of secret cop now, too? 1350 01:05:13,680 --> 01:05:16,160 [laughs] No. I'm a dog groomer, 1351 01:05:16,149 --> 01:05:18,852 but I watch and listen to a lot of true crime, 1352 01:05:18,985 --> 01:05:20,887 and the first rule is the husband did it. 1353 01:05:21,921 --> 01:05:23,356 Okay, well, 1354 01:05:23,490 --> 01:05:25,358 husband, boyfriend. Same difference. 1355 01:05:25,492 --> 01:05:26,993 You agree that he's guilty, right? 1356 01:05:27,127 --> 01:05:28,261 He is the perfect suspect. 1357 01:05:28,395 --> 01:05:29,662 [King] All right. Thank you. 1358 01:05:29,796 --> 01:05:31,970 But the second rule of true crime 1359 01:05:31,231 --> 01:05:33,500 is that it's never the perfect suspect. 1360 01:05:34,334 --> 01:05:35,668 Oh, my God. 1361 01:05:35,802 --> 01:05:38,505 I'm just sharing with you my experiences. 1362 01:05:38,638 --> 01:05:41,675 Your experiences? Listening to crime podcasts. 1363 01:05:41,808 --> 01:05:43,643 Well, hold on. And watching Dateline. 1364 01:05:43,777 --> 01:05:46,246 Okay. Well, that doesn't make you Sherlock Holmes. 1365 01:05:46,379 --> 01:05:47,747 Oh, thank you. [laughs] 1366 01:05:47,881 --> 01:05:49,816 No, you burn through enough cases, 1367 01:05:49,949 --> 01:05:52,519 and you start to see certain patterns. 1368 01:05:52,652 --> 01:05:54,587 But I leave the detective work to the forum lawyers. 1369 01:05:54,721 --> 01:05:56,189 Okay, good. Good. 1370 01:05:56,322 --> 01:05:57,857 Because we're not here to solve a mystery, okay? 1371 01:05:57,991 --> 01:05:59,959 All we're here to do is decide if we're positive 1372 01:06:00,930 --> 01:06:02,896 James Sythe killed Kendall Carter. That's it. 1373 01:06:03,290 --> 01:06:03,963 - [woman 2] May I? - Oh. 1374 01:06:04,970 --> 01:06:05,980 [med student] I'm not. 1375 01:06:07,670 --> 01:06:09,869 Old Quarry Road feeds into the highway. 1376 01:06:10,300 --> 01:06:12,739 When traffic's heavy, GPS will send you that way. 1377 01:06:12,872 --> 01:06:14,240 It gets busy. 1378 01:06:14,374 --> 01:06:16,743 Yeah, and at night, I mean, it's gnarly. 1379 01:06:16,876 --> 01:06:19,346 I nearly mowed down a deer once. 1380 01:06:19,479 --> 01:06:20,914 [man] What if that's what they thought? 1381 01:06:21,848 --> 01:06:23,160 [Aldworth] Who thought? 1382 01:06:25,218 --> 01:06:26,720 Whoever hit Kendall Carter. 1383 01:06:29,255 --> 01:06:30,957 Yeah, man. I mean, that all makes sense, 1384 01:06:31,910 --> 01:06:33,293 but, you know, what about our eyewitness? 1385 01:06:35,195 --> 01:06:36,629 Maybe he saw someone else? 1386 01:06:36,763 --> 01:06:38,231 Okay, hold up. Wait a minute. 1387 01:06:38,365 --> 01:06:40,433 Y'all got way too many "maybes" for my liking. 1388 01:06:40,567 --> 01:06:43,536 Yeah, and too many maybes is reasonable doubt. 1389 01:06:43,670 --> 01:06:44,738 [man] I agree with Justin. 1390 01:06:46,720 --> 01:06:47,730 Yeah. 1391 01:06:48,942 --> 01:06:50,377 Okay. Keiko? 1392 01:06:54,781 --> 01:06:55,782 Nellie? 1393 01:06:57,617 --> 01:07:01,121 I'm not sure any more that this young man is guilty. 1394 01:07:01,254 --> 01:07:03,289 Right. Okay. Anyone else? 1395 01:07:04,657 --> 01:07:05,592 Not guilty. 1396 01:07:06,126 --> 01:07:07,660 Okay. 1397 01:07:07,794 --> 01:07:09,863 [suspenseful music playing] 1398 01:07:14,670 --> 01:07:15,435 [sighs softly] 1399 01:07:15,568 --> 01:07:17,737 [man grunting] 1400 01:07:17,871 --> 01:07:21,441 I fell asleep on Highway 17 and woke up in a ditch. 1401 01:07:21,574 --> 01:07:23,760 Thank God the hospital was close. 1402 01:07:24,611 --> 01:07:27,130 Hmm. Okay. 1403 01:07:28,982 --> 01:07:30,216 Thank you for your time. 1404 01:07:30,350 --> 01:07:32,552 [man] Yep. 1405 01:07:32,686 --> 01:07:34,854 Yeah, we were street racing down Greek Row. 1406 01:07:34,988 --> 01:07:36,156 It was dumb. I know. 1407 01:07:42,429 --> 01:07:43,463 [chuckles softly] 1408 01:07:46,660 --> 01:07:47,100 [sighs] 1409 01:08:04,184 --> 01:08:05,185 Guilty. 1410 01:08:07,530 --> 01:08:08,540 Guilty. 1411 01:08:11,524 --> 01:08:12,659 Not guilty. 1412 01:08:15,280 --> 01:08:16,162 Not guilty. 1413 01:08:19,766 --> 01:08:20,734 Guilty. 1414 01:08:22,469 --> 01:08:24,871 All right. It looks like we're six to six. 1415 01:08:25,805 --> 01:08:27,140 We're deadlocked. 1416 01:08:27,273 --> 01:08:28,808 Okay, so what do we do now? 1417 01:08:28,942 --> 01:08:31,711 Feels like the more we talk, the less we know. 1418 01:08:31,845 --> 01:08:34,247 I'm so tired. 1419 01:08:34,381 --> 01:08:37,117 You're so stoned, dear. 1420 01:08:37,250 --> 01:08:38,918 - [mouthing] - Let's go back to the beginning. 1421 01:08:39,520 --> 01:08:40,920 Build a case piece by piece. 1422 01:08:41,540 --> 01:08:44,900 No, no. Let's stop wasting our damn time. 1423 01:08:44,224 --> 01:08:47,600 How about we all just take a breath. It's... 1424 01:08:47,193 --> 01:08:48,695 It's been a long day, but, you know, votes... 1425 01:08:48,828 --> 01:08:49,929 votes have changed, right? 1426 01:08:50,630 --> 01:08:51,464 The process is working. 1427 01:08:51,598 --> 01:08:54,300 [woman] No, it's not. You are wearing us down. 1428 01:08:54,434 --> 01:08:57,203 Talking a lot, but saying nothing. 1429 01:08:57,337 --> 01:08:59,572 I mean, hell, you go over anything enough times, 1430 01:08:59,706 --> 01:09:01,207 yeah, we'll start to question it. 1431 01:09:01,341 --> 01:09:03,610 Yeah. Like which shoes to wear. 1432 01:09:03,743 --> 01:09:06,120 Yeah. Look... [sighs] 1433 01:09:06,146 --> 01:09:08,882 We got all these theories, y'all, but no new evidence. 1434 01:09:09,150 --> 01:09:10,617 Well, yeah, but those theories are making 1435 01:09:10,750 --> 01:09:12,519 some of us question James Sythe's guilt. 1436 01:09:12,652 --> 01:09:15,288 No. No, no. You can question it all you want, 1437 01:09:15,422 --> 01:09:17,557 but I know he's guilty. 1438 01:09:19,250 --> 01:09:20,593 Just look at his damn neck. 1439 01:09:22,529 --> 01:09:24,297 Hey, my man. I know you got a picture of him 1440 01:09:24,431 --> 01:09:25,432 in that book of yours. 1441 01:09:27,400 --> 01:09:30,704 I mean, yeah, but it's not perfect, but... 1442 01:09:32,500 --> 01:09:34,174 Yes. See? Right there. 1443 01:09:34,307 --> 01:09:36,276 Snake and a crown. 1444 01:09:36,409 --> 01:09:37,911 That's the West Side Crowns. 1445 01:09:38,440 --> 01:09:40,613 They're the biggest drug pushers in the city. 1446 01:09:40,747 --> 01:09:41,981 How do you know that? 1447 01:09:42,115 --> 01:09:44,317 Because I run the Boys and Girls Club. 1448 01:09:44,451 --> 01:09:47,454 These guys are poisoning their own community. 1449 01:09:50,590 --> 01:09:51,791 This case is personal to you. 1450 01:09:51,925 --> 01:09:53,259 Yeah, well, you're damn right it is. 1451 01:09:57,970 --> 01:10:00,600 My little brother was 14 1452 01:10:00,734 --> 01:10:02,100 when he got inked. 1453 01:10:04,604 --> 01:10:08,740 A month before his 17th birthday, he was dead. 1454 01:10:08,208 --> 01:10:09,943 Caught a stray bullet in some... 1455 01:10:11,111 --> 01:10:13,747 tit-for-tat turf bullshit. 1456 01:10:16,149 --> 01:10:18,284 I'm sorry. I had no idea. 1457 01:10:18,418 --> 01:10:21,154 Yeah, that's right. You have no idea. 1458 01:10:24,657 --> 01:10:29,763 Look, Sythe did say that he left that life behind. 1459 01:10:29,896 --> 01:10:31,865 There's only one way to leave that crew. 1460 01:10:33,967 --> 01:10:35,335 So... 1461 01:10:35,468 --> 01:10:38,471 You can keep talking about your theories. 1462 01:10:38,605 --> 01:10:40,173 Look, people can change. 1463 01:10:40,306 --> 01:10:41,508 [King] Yeah. Keep telling yourself that. 1464 01:10:41,641 --> 01:10:42,809 I... I do. Every day. 1465 01:10:42,942 --> 01:10:44,811 Well, I drive a bus, 1466 01:10:44,944 --> 01:10:46,713 and I see the same people day in and day out, 1467 01:10:46,846 --> 01:10:48,181 and they do not change. 1468 01:10:48,314 --> 01:10:50,684 Well, then how am I sitting here? 1469 01:10:50,817 --> 01:10:51,851 What are you talking about? 1470 01:10:51,985 --> 01:10:52,986 I should be dead. 1471 01:10:54,540 --> 01:10:54,988 I should... 1472 01:10:56,289 --> 01:10:58,425 A little over four years ago, 1473 01:10:58,558 --> 01:10:59,859 I wrapped my car around a tree 1474 01:10:59,993 --> 01:11:01,928 with a blood alcohol level that, 1475 01:11:02,620 --> 01:11:03,396 you know, probably should have killed me 1476 01:11:03,530 --> 01:11:04,698 before I even got in the car 1477 01:11:04,831 --> 01:11:07,367 and somehow... [clears throat] 1478 01:11:07,534 --> 01:11:08,902 walked away with barely a scratch. 1479 01:11:09,350 --> 01:11:10,403 [King] Mmm. Lucky you. 1480 01:11:10,537 --> 01:11:12,305 [Justin] Yeah. Yeah, part of my sentence 1481 01:11:12,439 --> 01:11:13,907 was community service. 1482 01:11:14,400 --> 01:11:15,208 I spent three days a week in an elementary school 1483 01:11:15,342 --> 01:11:17,310 teaching kids how to write. 1484 01:11:17,444 --> 01:11:21,470 Uh... Alcoholics, we can charm anybody. 1485 01:11:21,181 --> 01:11:23,683 But the teacher I was reporting to, 1486 01:11:23,817 --> 01:11:25,510 I mean, she was Teflon. 1487 01:11:25,185 --> 01:11:27,153 She saw right through me. 1488 01:11:27,287 --> 01:11:28,855 And she... 1489 01:11:28,988 --> 01:11:31,591 She made me finally want to, you know, own my shit 1490 01:11:31,725 --> 01:11:34,494 and just take responsibility for myself. 1491 01:11:36,830 --> 01:11:37,797 I'm... [clears throat] 1492 01:11:37,931 --> 01:11:39,299 I'm still not sure what I did 1493 01:11:39,432 --> 01:11:40,867 to get a woman like her to give me a chance. 1494 01:11:41,000 --> 01:11:44,704 But her belief and believing in myself, 1495 01:11:44,838 --> 01:11:47,140 that I could change, that was... 1496 01:11:47,273 --> 01:11:49,242 That was, you know, the first step. 1497 01:11:50,276 --> 01:11:51,711 And... 1498 01:11:51,845 --> 01:11:53,246 Look, the, uh... 1499 01:11:53,380 --> 01:11:55,648 the journey never ends, I know that... 1500 01:11:55,782 --> 01:11:56,883 But... 1501 01:11:58,218 --> 01:11:59,119 that's... 1502 01:12:00,286 --> 01:12:01,921 that's four years. 1503 01:12:02,550 --> 01:12:04,991 And am I the same man that I was four years ago? No. 1504 01:12:05,892 --> 01:12:07,160 Absolutely not. 1505 01:12:07,293 --> 01:12:08,762 Yeah, well... 1506 01:12:08,895 --> 01:12:10,597 Now I can see... [chuckles] 1507 01:12:11,765 --> 01:12:12,866 You changed. 1508 01:12:14,340 --> 01:12:15,902 But guys like James Sythe, 1509 01:12:16,770 --> 01:12:18,438 they don't change. 1510 01:12:18,571 --> 01:12:20,807 Okay. Think back to his testimony. 1511 01:12:20,940 --> 01:12:24,644 That was raw and real, and I believed it. 1512 01:12:24,778 --> 01:12:26,746 Wait, hold on, gang. 1513 01:12:26,880 --> 01:12:28,815 If Sythe didn't do it, then who did? 1514 01:12:28,948 --> 01:12:30,917 We don't have to answer that. 1515 01:12:31,510 --> 01:12:32,719 So no one's going to pay for what happened to that girl? 1516 01:12:32,852 --> 01:12:35,221 - No, someone will pay. - How do you know that? 1517 01:12:35,355 --> 01:12:36,823 Because somebody always does. Look... 1518 01:12:36,956 --> 01:12:38,291 Look, I get how you feel, 1519 01:12:38,425 --> 01:12:41,940 but you can't let your feelings sway you. 1520 01:12:41,227 --> 01:12:42,796 You don't know anything about me, man. 1521 01:12:42,929 --> 01:12:43,997 All right. 1522 01:12:47,000 --> 01:12:49,135 How... how old's your daughter? 1523 01:12:49,269 --> 01:12:50,704 That's her on the key chain, right? 1524 01:12:53,573 --> 01:12:55,275 Yeah. She, um... 1525 01:12:55,408 --> 01:12:57,510 She turned 16 in March. 1526 01:12:57,644 --> 01:12:58,945 How often do you get to see her? 1527 01:13:01,481 --> 01:13:03,183 Not often enough. 1528 01:13:03,316 --> 01:13:05,885 You know, during the trial, I was sat 1529 01:13:06,190 --> 01:13:07,620 right in Kendall's parents' eyeline. 1530 01:13:07,754 --> 01:13:08,822 I could see... 1531 01:13:10,423 --> 01:13:12,125 I mean, their pain each day. 1532 01:13:12,258 --> 01:13:14,494 And, you know, what if she were your daughter? 1533 01:13:15,428 --> 01:13:16,763 [stammers] 1534 01:13:16,896 --> 01:13:18,765 You want justice, right? An eye for an eye. 1535 01:13:18,898 --> 01:13:20,633 Right. Yeah. 1536 01:13:20,767 --> 01:13:22,469 But then James Sythe's family was in court each day, too. 1537 01:13:22,602 --> 01:13:24,104 You know, his grandma and his niece. 1538 01:13:24,237 --> 01:13:25,939 Uh... 1539 01:13:26,720 --> 01:13:28,800 What if he were your son, right? 1540 01:13:29,609 --> 01:13:31,110 Wouldn't you want justice for him, too? 1541 01:13:33,446 --> 01:13:35,882 Yeah. Yeah, I suppose, I would. 1542 01:13:37,317 --> 01:13:38,451 [Robinson sighs] 1543 01:13:47,360 --> 01:13:49,362 [suspenseful music playing] 1544 01:14:14,521 --> 01:14:15,522 [engine roars] 1545 01:14:15,655 --> 01:14:16,723 [sighs] 1546 01:14:24,164 --> 01:14:26,166 So how can I help you? 1547 01:14:26,299 --> 01:14:27,667 Well, I just want to have a little chat 1548 01:14:27,801 --> 01:14:29,690 about what happened here. 1549 01:14:29,202 --> 01:14:30,737 Just have a little one on one. 1550 01:14:30,870 --> 01:14:32,238 Maybe I could get some more information 1551 01:14:32,372 --> 01:14:35,508 if something came to you new, you know? 1552 01:14:35,642 --> 01:14:39,446 Well, like I said at the trial, the police come by. 1553 01:14:39,579 --> 01:14:41,470 Showed me a picture, 1554 01:14:41,181 --> 01:14:42,716 asked me if he was the man I saw that night. 1555 01:14:42,849 --> 01:14:45,251 Mmm. They show you any other pictures? 1556 01:14:45,385 --> 01:14:47,870 Oh, no. They knew it was him. 1557 01:14:47,220 --> 01:14:49,823 They... They just needed me to confirm it. 1558 01:14:49,956 --> 01:14:51,124 Right. 1559 01:14:52,125 --> 01:14:53,393 I was happy to do so. 1560 01:14:53,526 --> 01:14:56,329 I mean, everyone was so generous. 1561 01:14:56,463 --> 01:14:59,332 And if I could say so, it felt pretty good 1562 01:14:59,466 --> 01:15:01,835 - to be needed again. - Mmm. 1563 01:15:02,602 --> 01:15:04,337 I'm sure it did. 1564 01:15:04,471 --> 01:15:06,473 All right. Well, if there's anything else I can do for you, 1565 01:15:06,606 --> 01:15:08,842 just give a holler. Tea is always hot. 1566 01:15:08,975 --> 01:15:10,310 [chuckles] Okay. Thank you so much. 1567 01:15:10,443 --> 01:15:11,411 Thanks for your time, sir. 1568 01:15:11,544 --> 01:15:12,912 Uh, James Sythe... 1569 01:15:15,749 --> 01:15:18,510 He did kill that girl, right? 1570 01:15:22,789 --> 01:15:24,900 [exhales] 1571 01:15:26,693 --> 01:15:29,662 Okay, so does anybody else want to change their vote? 1572 01:15:29,796 --> 01:15:31,231 [chuckles] 1573 01:15:32,980 --> 01:15:33,466 Uh, well... 1574 01:15:35,268 --> 01:15:36,302 It doesn't matter anyway. 1575 01:15:36,436 --> 01:15:38,171 [Aldworth] What do you mean? 1576 01:15:38,304 --> 01:15:40,774 Because I haven't changed my mind. 1577 01:15:40,907 --> 01:15:42,108 All right, well, let's just keep talking. 1578 01:15:42,242 --> 01:15:45,345 No, no, I'm done talking. 1579 01:15:46,460 --> 01:15:47,480 Marcus. 1580 01:15:47,614 --> 01:15:50,650 So what? You're gonna tell the judge, we... 1581 01:15:50,784 --> 01:15:52,819 we can't reach a verdict? 1582 01:15:52,952 --> 01:15:54,621 [woman] It is what it is. 1583 01:15:54,754 --> 01:15:56,456 But we're actually making progress. 1584 01:15:56,589 --> 01:15:59,526 - [scoffs] Progress? - Yeah. 1585 01:15:59,659 --> 01:16:01,895 How can we continue if we can't even reach a verdict? 1586 01:16:02,280 --> 01:16:04,631 We've been at this for I don't even know how long. 1587 01:16:05,432 --> 01:16:06,700 My kids need me. 1588 01:16:08,501 --> 01:16:10,170 I'm just trying to do my job here. 1589 01:16:11,304 --> 01:16:13,840 Okay? Um... 1590 01:16:13,973 --> 01:16:15,909 Courtney, what about you? Do you want to keep going? 1591 01:16:16,420 --> 01:16:18,645 I don't know. Look, he yelled at her. 1592 01:16:18,778 --> 01:16:21,448 He grabbed her arm. He called her a *****. 1593 01:16:21,581 --> 01:16:23,683 He was possessive and temperamental. 1594 01:16:23,817 --> 01:16:26,686 No, he was abusive. Screw him. 1595 01:16:27,921 --> 01:16:29,656 Yeah. You're right. 1596 01:16:30,457 --> 01:16:31,758 Screw him. 1597 01:16:31,925 --> 01:16:33,727 Great. [chuckles] For the third time, 1598 01:16:33,860 --> 01:16:35,128 I get to go home and tell my husband, 1599 01:16:35,261 --> 01:16:36,196 "Guess what, honey? 1600 01:16:36,329 --> 01:16:38,631 [laughs] I did nothing." 1601 01:16:38,765 --> 01:16:40,800 He gets a real kick out of that. 1602 01:16:40,934 --> 01:16:43,200 I'm sorry, Denice. I'm not changing my vote. 1603 01:16:43,870 --> 01:16:45,372 Neither am I. 1604 01:16:45,505 --> 01:16:47,507 Yeah. Me, too. 1605 01:16:52,245 --> 01:16:53,513 [man] So what do we do then? 1606 01:16:54,180 --> 01:16:55,181 Um... 1607 01:16:56,649 --> 01:16:58,418 there's one thing we could try. 1608 01:16:59,853 --> 01:17:02,455 [sighs] Madam Foreperson. 1609 01:17:04,240 --> 01:17:06,260 Sending a jury to visit a crime scene 1610 01:17:06,159 --> 01:17:07,560 once deliberations have begun 1611 01:17:07,694 --> 01:17:10,960 is not something I would typically allow. 1612 01:17:10,230 --> 01:17:11,598 With all due respect, Your Honor, 1613 01:17:11,731 --> 01:17:14,567 this has not been a typical deliberation. 1614 01:17:14,701 --> 01:17:16,403 But I do think it will be beneficial 1615 01:17:16,536 --> 01:17:18,204 in helping us reach a verdict. 1616 01:17:18,338 --> 01:17:19,239 I see. 1617 01:17:22,800 --> 01:17:23,376 Mr. Resnick. Any objections? 1618 01:17:24,411 --> 01:17:25,745 No, Your Honor. 1619 01:17:25,879 --> 01:17:27,113 Okay, Miss Killebrew? 1620 01:17:29,149 --> 01:17:30,850 The State's fine with it. 1621 01:17:30,984 --> 01:17:32,180 All right, then. 1622 01:17:32,919 --> 01:17:35,422 Here are the rules. 1623 01:17:35,555 --> 01:17:37,924 During your visit, you are not to speak 1624 01:17:38,580 --> 01:17:39,893 to anyone outside of your jury panel, 1625 01:17:40,260 --> 01:17:44,597 nor are you to speak to each other about this case. 1626 01:17:44,731 --> 01:17:46,633 All right, you are there to view the locations 1627 01:17:46,766 --> 01:17:49,769 in and around where the crime took place. 1628 01:17:49,903 --> 01:17:54,441 And you are not to collect evidence of any kind. 1629 01:17:54,574 --> 01:17:56,810 Does everyone understand these rules? 1630 01:17:56,943 --> 01:17:58,845 - Yes, ma'am. - [jurors] Yes, Your Honor. 1631 01:17:58,978 --> 01:18:00,130 All right, then. 1632 01:18:01,314 --> 01:18:02,582 This court is adjourned. 1633 01:18:04,751 --> 01:18:06,519 Hey. Hey. Can... Can we talk? 1634 01:18:08,488 --> 01:18:10,490 Yeah, great. Great. I'll see you there. Thanks. 1635 01:18:12,125 --> 01:18:13,326 [knock at door] 1636 01:18:16,396 --> 01:18:17,931 [knocks at door] 1637 01:18:26,539 --> 01:18:27,941 Hello? 1638 01:18:28,740 --> 01:18:30,510 Oh, hey, are you Allison Crewson? 1639 01:18:30,643 --> 01:18:32,345 Yes, I am. Yeah. Who are you? 1640 01:18:32,479 --> 01:18:34,800 I'm, um... I'm Faith Killebrew. 1641 01:18:34,247 --> 01:18:36,816 I'm a prosecutor with the District Attorney's office. 1642 01:18:36,950 --> 01:18:39,190 Do you mind if we talk? 1643 01:18:39,152 --> 01:18:40,954 I was just about to lay down, but what is this about? 1644 01:18:41,870 --> 01:18:43,256 It'll only be a minute. 1645 01:18:43,390 --> 01:18:45,191 - Okay. Come in. - Okay. Thank you. 1646 01:18:51,598 --> 01:18:53,330 Uh, I'm sorry for the intrusion. 1647 01:18:53,166 --> 01:18:54,901 I won't be long. 1648 01:18:55,350 --> 01:18:56,836 I'm following up on a... 1649 01:18:56,970 --> 01:18:59,339 on a few different accidents from October last year, 1650 01:18:59,472 --> 01:19:01,341 just doing routine checks on any cars 1651 01:19:01,508 --> 01:19:04,177 that were serviced for major body damage around that time. 1652 01:19:04,310 --> 01:19:05,412 Okay. 1653 01:19:05,545 --> 01:19:07,380 So on October 25th last year, 1654 01:19:07,514 --> 01:19:10,984 did you own a 1996 green Toyota 4Runner? 1655 01:19:11,117 --> 01:19:12,652 Yes. 1656 01:19:12,786 --> 01:19:14,540 Mmm-hmm. And do you remember having any body work 1657 01:19:14,187 --> 01:19:16,556 - done on it around that time? - Yeah. 1658 01:19:16,690 --> 01:19:19,693 Okay. And how was your car damaged? 1659 01:19:19,826 --> 01:19:21,561 My husband, Justin, hit a deer. 1660 01:19:21,695 --> 01:19:23,329 Okay. Any idea where? 1661 01:19:24,464 --> 01:19:25,999 Up on Brimstone Pass. 1662 01:19:26,866 --> 01:19:27,967 You sure? 1663 01:19:28,101 --> 01:19:30,970 [laughs] Yeah. 1664 01:19:31,104 --> 01:19:33,139 Could it have been Old Quarry Road? Or... 1665 01:19:34,708 --> 01:19:36,409 No, it was Brimstone Pass. 1666 01:19:37,977 --> 01:19:38,978 You're positive. 1667 01:19:40,460 --> 01:19:41,214 Positive. 1668 01:19:43,216 --> 01:19:45,752 Okay. Great. Well, that's all I have. 1669 01:19:47,687 --> 01:19:50,223 Thank you very much for your time, Mrs. Crewson. 1670 01:19:50,357 --> 01:19:52,826 And, uh, congratulations. When are you due? 1671 01:19:54,600 --> 01:19:55,395 Uh... 1672 01:19:55,528 --> 01:19:56,763 Yeah, any day now. 1673 01:19:56,896 --> 01:19:58,231 [laughs] Well, good luck with that. 1674 01:19:58,365 --> 01:20:00,330 You want me to do anything before I go? 1675 01:20:00,166 --> 01:20:01,534 - No, no. No. - Okay. Well, I'll just see myself out. 1676 01:20:01,668 --> 01:20:02,936 - No. I'll get you... - No, you stay there. 1677 01:20:03,103 --> 01:20:04,904 - Okay, all right. - No, it's good. [laughs] 1678 01:20:05,380 --> 01:20:05,905 - Have a good one. - Thank you. Thanks for your time. 1679 01:20:06,390 --> 01:20:06,573 - Bye. - Bye, now. 1680 01:20:07,374 --> 01:20:08,308 [door closes] 1681 01:20:08,441 --> 01:20:10,110 [tense music playing] 1682 01:20:23,390 --> 01:20:25,225 [bell ringing] 1683 01:20:28,495 --> 01:20:30,730 Hey. Sorry I couldn't meet you earlier. 1684 01:20:30,864 --> 01:20:32,532 - No worries. - What's on your mind? 1685 01:20:32,665 --> 01:20:33,600 The trial. 1686 01:20:33,733 --> 01:20:35,568 Well, yeah, I figured. 1687 01:20:35,702 --> 01:20:37,270 It's headed for a hung jury. 1688 01:20:37,404 --> 01:20:38,438 [man] Justin! 1689 01:20:39,372 --> 01:20:41,307 - Thanks. - Enjoy. 1690 01:20:41,441 --> 01:20:43,910 - I got you a coffee. - Thanks. 1691 01:20:44,770 --> 01:20:45,879 Obviously, I want to acquit the guy, 1692 01:20:46,120 --> 01:20:48,381 but if the jury hangs, it's a mistrial, right? 1693 01:20:48,515 --> 01:20:50,884 - That's right. - So problem solved. 1694 01:20:51,170 --> 01:20:52,819 Well, given all the press on this case, 1695 01:20:52,952 --> 01:20:55,550 the public's going to demand a retrial. 1696 01:20:55,188 --> 01:20:57,390 We're just gonna have to do it all over again with Sythe. 1697 01:20:57,524 --> 01:20:59,359 Unless the District Attorney's office decides 1698 01:20:59,492 --> 01:21:02,962 that he's not the guy, then they'll find the guy. 1699 01:21:03,960 --> 01:21:05,298 And there's no way that this case ends without a verdict. 1700 01:21:05,432 --> 01:21:07,834 Once they get that, then, yeah, it's over. Then it's done. 1701 01:21:07,967 --> 01:21:09,803 So you're saying I need a verdict? 1702 01:21:10,503 --> 01:21:11,671 I'm afraid so. 1703 01:21:26,453 --> 01:21:27,620 [sighs] 1704 01:21:28,988 --> 01:21:31,240 Hey, can you meet me at County? 1705 01:21:51,811 --> 01:21:52,679 [Allison] Hey. 1706 01:21:53,680 --> 01:21:56,490 Hey. Everything okay? 1707 01:21:58,840 --> 01:22:00,320 Just checking the car. Might have a buyer. 1708 01:22:06,726 --> 01:22:08,194 Where'd you hit that deer again? 1709 01:22:10,330 --> 01:22:12,432 Up on Brimstone Pass, right? 1710 01:22:14,340 --> 01:22:14,901 Mmm. 1711 01:22:16,736 --> 01:22:18,672 Are you sure that it wasn't Old Quarry Road? 1712 01:22:19,906 --> 01:22:21,207 I'm positive. 1713 01:22:22,142 --> 01:22:23,109 That's... 1714 01:22:23,910 --> 01:22:25,945 Just that's ex... 1715 01:22:26,790 --> 01:22:28,515 "Positive," that's what I said to the... 1716 01:22:28,648 --> 01:22:30,216 prosecutor from your trial 1717 01:22:30,350 --> 01:22:32,552 when she just interrogated me in our living room. 1718 01:22:33,787 --> 01:22:35,880 - What? She was here. - Yeah. 1719 01:22:36,990 --> 01:22:38,892 I looked her up. She wanted to know about your accident. 1720 01:22:40,493 --> 01:22:41,494 That-- 1721 01:22:43,196 --> 01:22:44,597 What'd you tell her? 1722 01:22:44,731 --> 01:22:45,699 The truth. 1723 01:22:48,301 --> 01:22:49,369 That you hit a deer 1724 01:22:50,336 --> 01:22:51,671 up on Brimstone Pass. 1725 01:22:53,139 --> 01:22:55,108 Okay. Good. 1726 01:22:56,743 --> 01:22:57,877 That is the truth, right? 1727 01:23:00,380 --> 01:23:02,480 Did you take the shortcut... 1728 01:23:02,215 --> 01:23:03,750 home through Old Quarry that night? 1729 01:23:05,952 --> 01:23:07,887 Did you stop at Rowdy's Hideaway? 1730 01:23:12,125 --> 01:23:13,159 [Allison sighs] 1731 01:23:19,299 --> 01:23:20,333 Did you drink? 1732 01:23:21,968 --> 01:23:23,200 [sighs softly] 1733 01:23:28,975 --> 01:23:29,976 Did you? 1734 01:23:31,945 --> 01:23:34,140 Justin. Did you drink? 1735 01:23:35,548 --> 01:23:38,840 - Talk to me. - No, no, I didn't drink. 1736 01:23:38,218 --> 01:23:40,220 I didn't drink. Okay? I... 1737 01:23:43,456 --> 01:23:45,125 I stopped and I [stammering]... 1738 01:23:45,258 --> 01:23:46,793 I ordered the drink, but I didn't touch it. 1739 01:23:46,926 --> 01:23:48,828 Ordered, but didn't drink. Why would I believe that? 1740 01:23:48,962 --> 01:23:50,663 - Because that's the truth. I promise. I swear. - You swear? 1741 01:23:50,797 --> 01:23:52,465 Why should I believe that? Why should I believe anything 1742 01:23:52,632 --> 01:23:53,900 - that you're saying anymore? - I promise. I swear to you. 1743 01:23:54,340 --> 01:23:55,135 - I swear to you. - You swear to me? 1744 01:23:55,268 --> 01:23:56,169 - I swear. - Don't lie to me. 1745 01:23:56,302 --> 01:23:57,303 I'm not lying. I promise. 1746 01:23:57,437 --> 01:23:59,239 I promise. That is the truth. 1747 01:23:59,372 --> 01:24:00,173 Okay? 1748 01:24:01,541 --> 01:24:02,575 Look, it... 1749 01:24:04,444 --> 01:24:05,445 It... 1750 01:24:07,347 --> 01:24:09,683 It was the twins' due date and I couldn't deal 1751 01:24:09,816 --> 01:24:10,817 with the feelings that I was having. 1752 01:24:10,984 --> 01:24:12,686 I couldn't deal with them, 1753 01:24:12,819 --> 01:24:14,454 so I didn't want to bring them home and put them on you. 1754 01:24:15,188 --> 01:24:16,456 So I went there. 1755 01:24:16,589 --> 01:24:18,191 I sat there for a while, and then I... 1756 01:24:18,324 --> 01:24:20,126 and then I came home. 1757 01:24:20,260 --> 01:24:22,328 [voice shaking] Why didn't you tell me any of this? 1758 01:24:22,462 --> 01:24:24,130 Why did you keep this from me? 1759 01:24:24,264 --> 01:24:25,331 - I wanted... I wanted to. - You could've talked to me. 1760 01:24:25,465 --> 01:24:26,566 But you were in so much pain. 1761 01:24:26,700 --> 01:24:28,968 Of course I was in pain. 1762 01:24:29,102 --> 01:24:30,704 I kept thinking that I was somehow responsible, 1763 01:24:30,837 --> 01:24:32,205 that it was my fault, that it's still my... 1764 01:24:32,339 --> 01:24:33,740 No. No. It was not your fault. 1765 01:24:33,873 --> 01:24:35,208 - They were my babies. - It's not... It's not... 1766 01:24:35,342 --> 01:24:36,976 - They were our babies. - I know. 1767 01:24:37,110 --> 01:24:40,130 None... None... None of this is your fault, okay? 1768 01:24:40,146 --> 01:24:42,215 We were both hurting. It still hurts. 1769 01:24:44,751 --> 01:24:45,852 I'm still hurting. 1770 01:24:49,956 --> 01:24:50,857 Me, too. 1771 01:24:52,592 --> 01:24:54,600 Yeah. Yeah. 1772 01:24:58,465 --> 01:25:00,660 [sighs] 1773 01:25:00,200 --> 01:25:02,469 I'm not doing this alone. 1774 01:25:02,602 --> 01:25:04,504 No, you're not. You're not. 1775 01:25:04,637 --> 01:25:05,839 You are not. 1776 01:25:05,972 --> 01:25:08,875 I will protect our family. I will. 1777 01:25:11,770 --> 01:25:12,512 I promise. Okay? 1778 01:25:15,749 --> 01:25:17,684 Hey, come here. Come here. 1779 01:25:18,918 --> 01:25:20,200 [sighs] 1780 01:25:33,767 --> 01:25:35,680 What the hell is going on? 1781 01:25:35,201 --> 01:25:37,103 - Ugh, I need to see him. - Why? 1782 01:25:37,237 --> 01:25:38,438 I need him to look me in the eye 1783 01:25:38,571 --> 01:25:39,739 and tell me he didn't do it. 1784 01:25:41,675 --> 01:25:42,742 So you're having doubts? 1785 01:25:42,876 --> 01:25:43,910 I'm right. You're doubting it? 1786 01:25:44,440 --> 01:25:45,912 I... I don't know. 1787 01:25:46,460 --> 01:25:47,547 What do you mean you don't know? 1788 01:25:47,681 --> 01:25:48,915 Come on. You know something isn't right here. 1789 01:25:49,490 --> 01:25:51,170 The jury knows it. It's just... 1790 01:25:51,151 --> 01:25:52,886 Can you prove that's what happened? 1791 01:25:53,190 --> 01:25:55,221 Can you prove it didn't? Can you? 1792 01:25:55,355 --> 01:25:57,290 [Faith] I don't know. Just get me in there. 1793 01:26:01,194 --> 01:26:02,429 [door buzzes] 1794 01:26:08,735 --> 01:26:09,936 [door slams] 1795 01:26:13,730 --> 01:26:14,140 What are you doing here? 1796 01:26:15,942 --> 01:26:16,910 Have a seat. 1797 01:26:18,611 --> 01:26:19,779 I shouldn't be talking to you. 1798 01:26:20,814 --> 01:26:21,781 It's okay. 1799 01:26:28,121 --> 01:26:29,289 What do you want? 1800 01:26:30,590 --> 01:26:32,525 Same thing as you. 1801 01:26:32,659 --> 01:26:34,127 Justice for Kendall Carter. 1802 01:26:34,260 --> 01:26:36,162 So go find the son of a ***** who did it. 1803 01:26:38,832 --> 01:26:40,500 Look, there's no jury, 1804 01:26:40,633 --> 01:26:43,169 no judge, no cameras. So just... 1805 01:26:43,303 --> 01:26:44,604 tell me what happened that night. 1806 01:26:44,738 --> 01:26:46,740 I told you. I went home. 1807 01:26:48,908 --> 01:26:50,877 Right, but first, you... 1808 01:26:51,440 --> 01:26:53,790 you followed her, right? 1809 01:26:54,247 --> 01:26:55,615 Yeah. I mean, she was wasted. 1810 01:26:56,983 --> 01:26:58,985 Oh, no. So you felt angry 1811 01:26:59,119 --> 01:27:01,121 and, I don't know, sick of being played? 1812 01:27:01,287 --> 01:27:03,623 No, no, that wasn't it. Okay? 1813 01:27:04,958 --> 01:27:06,760 It's just how Kenny was. 1814 01:27:06,893 --> 01:27:08,928 She'd get all worked up, you know, talk this big game, 1815 01:27:09,620 --> 01:27:11,664 and the next day, it'd be like nothing happened. 1816 01:27:11,798 --> 01:27:13,366 So she just needed to chill out. 1817 01:27:14,434 --> 01:27:15,435 Right. 1818 01:27:16,836 --> 01:27:17,871 Yes, okay, I... 1819 01:27:19,372 --> 01:27:22,509 I know our relationship wasn't perfect. 1820 01:27:24,678 --> 01:27:25,912 But we did love each other. 1821 01:27:28,982 --> 01:27:30,717 Now, listen, lady... 1822 01:27:30,850 --> 01:27:33,319 I've done a lot of things in my life 1823 01:27:33,453 --> 01:27:34,587 that I'm not proud of. 1824 01:27:36,623 --> 01:27:39,250 But I didn't do this. 1825 01:27:43,363 --> 01:27:44,464 The biggest regret... 1826 01:27:46,266 --> 01:27:47,367 of my life... 1827 01:27:49,369 --> 01:27:50,637 is that I didn't go after Kendall 1828 01:27:50,770 --> 01:27:52,500 in my car that night. 1829 01:27:53,940 --> 01:27:54,974 Because if I did... 1830 01:27:56,876 --> 01:27:58,311 Kenny would still be alive. 1831 01:28:01,648 --> 01:28:02,482 I'm done. 1832 01:28:04,984 --> 01:28:05,985 [bangs door] 1833 01:28:15,362 --> 01:28:16,396 [door closes] 1834 01:28:18,431 --> 01:28:20,233 [bailiff] All right, everybody, on the bus. Let's go. 1835 01:28:23,737 --> 01:28:24,738 [laughing] 1836 01:28:33,880 --> 01:28:35,281 [Courtney laughs] 1837 01:28:37,951 --> 01:28:39,519 [snoring] 1838 01:28:57,437 --> 01:28:59,806 Ah. Look, but don't touch. 1839 01:29:00,840 --> 01:29:01,875 Put it back. 1840 01:29:10,417 --> 01:29:12,419 [country music playing on speakers] 1841 01:30:01,601 --> 01:30:03,937 [bailiff] Okay, y'all. You ready to go? 1842 01:30:04,104 --> 01:30:06,172 [music fades] 1843 01:30:27,627 --> 01:30:29,596 [tense music playing] 1844 01:30:36,369 --> 01:30:38,438 So this is where they fought. 1845 01:31:42,902 --> 01:31:44,270 Hey, you all right? 1846 01:31:45,605 --> 01:31:47,700 Yeah. I'm fine, thanks. 1847 01:31:47,640 --> 01:31:48,641 Nah, man. 1848 01:31:50,410 --> 01:31:52,112 You haven't been fine since the start. 1849 01:31:54,547 --> 01:31:56,583 I think you've been playing us this whole time. 1850 01:31:58,510 --> 01:31:58,985 I don't know what you mean. 1851 01:32:01,454 --> 01:32:03,123 The day you got on the jury, you were... 1852 01:32:04,524 --> 01:32:07,260 puking in the bathroom. 1853 01:32:07,394 --> 01:32:09,996 All that stuff with the Flower Man cop and those papers. 1854 01:32:12,198 --> 01:32:13,266 You claim to be the voice of reason, 1855 01:32:13,433 --> 01:32:15,680 but you're really just... 1856 01:32:15,201 --> 01:32:16,503 telling us what we want to hear. 1857 01:32:16,636 --> 01:32:18,138 [clinks] 1858 01:32:25,478 --> 01:32:26,880 Now, I don't know what game you're playing, man, 1859 01:32:27,130 --> 01:32:28,114 but I see you. 1860 01:32:31,751 --> 01:32:34,220 Do I know exactly what happened that night? 1861 01:32:34,354 --> 01:32:35,789 No. 1862 01:32:35,922 --> 01:32:37,891 But neither do you. 1863 01:32:39,359 --> 01:32:41,728 And you can't be any more sure 1864 01:32:41,861 --> 01:32:44,230 that James Sythe got in his car 1865 01:32:44,364 --> 01:32:47,300 and drove home that night than I'm sure he... 1866 01:32:49,135 --> 01:32:50,870 picked up one of these rocks 1867 01:32:51,400 --> 01:32:52,839 and bashed that poor girl's head in. 1868 01:32:54,507 --> 01:32:56,900 And threw her body in the creek. 1869 01:33:02,482 --> 01:33:04,551 Jesus, man. 1870 01:33:04,684 --> 01:33:06,786 - You nearly slipped. - Yeah. [clears throat] 1871 01:33:12,250 --> 01:33:14,494 Maybe that hiker was right. 1872 01:33:14,627 --> 01:33:16,896 - Could have slipped. - Yeah, maybe. Maybe. 1873 01:33:18,264 --> 01:33:19,399 But it doesn't matter. 1874 01:33:23,200 --> 01:33:25,739 That piece of shit left her there that night... 1875 01:33:26,706 --> 01:33:28,842 alone, to die. 1876 01:33:28,975 --> 01:33:30,176 In a ditch. 1877 01:33:32,479 --> 01:33:34,114 Her death is on him. 1878 01:33:34,247 --> 01:33:36,916 Which is why I will never acquit James Sythe. 1879 01:33:38,218 --> 01:33:39,219 Ever. 1880 01:33:43,490 --> 01:33:44,958 This trial ends in only two ways, 1881 01:33:45,910 --> 01:33:47,894 either with a conviction or a hung jury. 1882 01:33:48,280 --> 01:33:49,229 [Denice claps] All right. 1883 01:33:49,362 --> 01:33:50,797 Is everybody ready to head home? 1884 01:33:53,266 --> 01:33:54,834 Is everybody done here, please? 1885 01:33:56,736 --> 01:33:57,704 [Marcus] Yeah. 1886 01:34:02,509 --> 01:34:03,443 Okay, let's go. 1887 01:34:06,813 --> 01:34:08,140 [Denice] Have you seen enough? 1888 01:34:08,882 --> 01:34:09,849 Yeah. 1889 01:34:09,983 --> 01:34:12,520 [engines start] 1890 01:34:20,727 --> 01:34:23,730 [suspenseful music playing] 1891 01:34:25,980 --> 01:34:26,599 [engine starts] 1892 01:34:28,680 --> 01:34:30,437 [country music playing on speakers] 1893 01:34:57,497 --> 01:34:58,631 [sighs] 1894 01:35:14,381 --> 01:35:15,415 [banging] 1895 01:35:15,548 --> 01:35:16,583 All rise! 1896 01:35:37,103 --> 01:35:38,338 Madam Foreperson. 1897 01:35:41,708 --> 01:35:43,309 Has the jury reached a verdict? 1898 01:35:44,144 --> 01:35:45,845 Yes, Your Honor. 1899 01:35:45,979 --> 01:35:48,480 And is that verdict unanimous? 1900 01:35:48,848 --> 01:35:49,949 Yes, Your Honor. 1901 01:36:17,310 --> 01:36:20,800 Will the defendant please stand for the reading of the verdict? 1902 01:36:26,686 --> 01:36:30,890 "In the matter of the State of Georgia vs. James Michael Sythe, 1903 01:36:31,240 --> 01:36:35,929 case number C-R-20211715532, 1904 01:36:37,230 --> 01:36:38,798 we, the jury 1905 01:36:38,932 --> 01:36:41,568 find the defendant, James Michael Sythe 1906 01:36:41,701 --> 01:36:44,270 guilty of count one malice murder. 1907 01:36:45,505 --> 01:36:47,540 Signed and dated this day, 1908 01:36:47,674 --> 01:36:50,443 Denice Aldworth, Foreperson." 1909 01:36:50,577 --> 01:36:51,878 [sighs] 1910 01:36:52,120 --> 01:36:53,113 Madam Foreperson? 1911 01:36:54,180 --> 01:36:55,548 To the best of your knowledge, 1912 01:36:55,682 --> 01:36:57,917 was this your verdict in the jury room? 1913 01:36:58,840 --> 01:37:00,553 Was it freely and voluntarily given? 1914 01:37:00,687 --> 01:37:02,880 And is this still your verdict? 1915 01:37:03,356 --> 01:37:04,891 [Denice] Yes, Your Honor. 1916 01:37:05,250 --> 01:37:06,292 [Judge Thelma] Very well. 1917 01:37:06,426 --> 01:37:08,261 Then the defendant is hereby remanded 1918 01:37:08,395 --> 01:37:10,964 to the custody of the State. 1919 01:37:11,970 --> 01:37:13,266 Sentencing will be at a later date. 1920 01:37:17,570 --> 01:37:19,606 [softly] Oh, James. 1921 01:37:23,877 --> 01:37:25,945 Thank you for your service. 1922 01:37:26,790 --> 01:37:27,247 It is now concluded. 1923 01:37:28,748 --> 01:37:30,160 This court is adjourned. 1924 01:37:38,124 --> 01:37:39,292 [sighs] 1925 01:38:16,960 --> 01:38:17,970 [groans softly] 1926 01:38:23,103 --> 01:38:25,505 [sirens blaring in distance] 1927 01:38:29,442 --> 01:38:31,544 [tense music playing] 1928 01:38:47,494 --> 01:38:48,862 [sighs] 1929 01:38:58,538 --> 01:39:00,707 Hey. Good. Right there. 1930 01:39:02,475 --> 01:39:04,177 - Hey. - Hey. 1931 01:39:04,310 --> 01:39:05,645 - What time does it start? - Soon. I'm going to head out. 1932 01:39:05,812 --> 01:39:06,946 You sure you want to go? 1933 01:39:07,647 --> 01:39:08,715 Hey! Justin. 1934 01:39:08,882 --> 01:39:10,750 He wasn't a good guy. 1935 01:39:10,884 --> 01:39:12,152 It's not your fault. 1936 01:39:14,487 --> 01:39:15,689 I didn't stand up for him. 1937 01:39:17,524 --> 01:39:19,259 I told them what they needed to hear, 1938 01:39:19,392 --> 01:39:20,660 and said he couldn't change. 1939 01:39:22,128 --> 01:39:23,930 And I have to live with that, so... 1940 01:39:27,801 --> 01:39:28,735 The least I can do is be there. 1941 01:39:31,171 --> 01:39:32,238 [door closes] 1942 01:39:34,507 --> 01:39:35,742 Hi, peanut. 1943 01:39:50,590 --> 01:39:51,491 This came for you. 1944 01:40:24,791 --> 01:40:27,660 Will the defendant please stand for sentencing? 1945 01:40:31,564 --> 01:40:37,170 The murder of Kendall Carter was violent and senseless. 1946 01:40:37,303 --> 01:40:39,939 The jury has found you guilty of that murder, 1947 01:40:40,730 --> 01:40:43,143 for which this court sentences you as follows. 1948 01:40:44,110 --> 01:40:46,446 Count one, malice murder. 1949 01:40:48,181 --> 01:40:49,449 Life in prison 1950 01:40:49,582 --> 01:40:51,451 without the possibility of parole. 1951 01:40:53,319 --> 01:40:55,355 The defendant is hereby remanded 1952 01:40:55,488 --> 01:40:57,190 to the Department of Corrections 1953 01:40:57,323 --> 01:40:59,459 to serve the rest of his life in prison. 1954 01:41:21,781 --> 01:41:24,351 [suspenseful music playing] 1955 01:41:24,517 --> 01:41:26,520 [Allison] My husband, Justin, hit a deer. 1956 01:41:26,186 --> 01:41:27,654 [Justin] My wife is of a high-risk pregnancy. 1957 01:41:41,768 --> 01:41:43,536 [Judge Thelma] This court is now adjourned. 1958 01:42:04,924 --> 01:42:05,925 Hey. 1959 01:42:07,660 --> 01:42:09,195 I'm surprised you came today. 1960 01:42:12,399 --> 01:42:13,900 I wanted to see this through. 1961 01:42:14,701 --> 01:42:15,802 Yeah. Me too. 1962 01:42:21,174 --> 01:42:22,242 You look tired. 1963 01:42:24,711 --> 01:42:25,745 Likewise. 1964 01:42:27,180 --> 01:42:28,548 Well, I have a new baby at home. 1965 01:42:29,816 --> 01:42:30,917 That's not what I meant. 1966 01:42:38,358 --> 01:42:39,793 Congratulations on winning your election. 1967 01:42:39,926 --> 01:42:41,861 - I saw it in the paper. - Oh, yeah. Thank you. 1968 01:42:41,995 --> 01:42:43,697 It's a pretty big deal. You must have worked hard for it. 1969 01:42:43,863 --> 01:42:44,864 Oh, I did. 1970 01:42:47,200 --> 01:42:49,436 There's a lot of good you can do in that job, I'd imagine. 1971 01:42:50,603 --> 01:42:51,671 Sometimes. 1972 01:42:53,640 --> 01:42:55,275 It's not as easy as you think, though. 1973 01:42:56,976 --> 01:42:58,411 Never is. 1974 01:42:58,578 --> 01:43:00,780 Mmm. Sometimes you try and do the right thing 1975 01:43:00,914 --> 01:43:02,515 only to realize you got it all wrong. 1976 01:43:07,954 --> 01:43:10,423 And when you figure things out, 1977 01:43:10,590 --> 01:43:12,625 you realize the guy you're after isn't some... 1978 01:43:13,626 --> 01:43:15,261 psycho. 1979 01:43:15,428 --> 01:43:16,963 He's not even really a criminal. 1980 01:43:18,898 --> 01:43:20,567 He's just a regular guy. 1981 01:43:24,604 --> 01:43:25,939 What if it was an accident? 1982 01:43:26,106 --> 01:43:27,240 This is no accident. 1983 01:43:30,777 --> 01:43:33,130 It's impossible to prove, either way. 1984 01:43:33,146 --> 01:43:35,248 Just like him not realizing at the time 1985 01:43:35,382 --> 01:43:37,117 that he hit someone with his car. It's... 1986 01:43:40,820 --> 01:43:42,880 You just have to trust him. 1987 01:43:44,900 --> 01:43:45,191 Why would I do that? 1988 01:43:46,493 --> 01:43:48,762 Because he's a good person. 1989 01:43:48,895 --> 01:43:51,197 He was caught in terrible circumstances. 1990 01:43:51,331 --> 01:43:53,733 Mmm-hmm. No, you're right. This is a... 1991 01:43:53,867 --> 01:43:55,201 [chuckles] It's a tough one. 1992 01:43:57,837 --> 01:43:59,305 He has a family depending on him, 1993 01:43:59,439 --> 01:44:01,174 just like you have people depending on you. 1994 01:44:02,475 --> 01:44:03,810 And what about justice? 1995 01:44:10,150 --> 01:44:11,818 Well, sometimes... 1996 01:44:11,951 --> 01:44:14,187 the truth isn't justice. 1997 01:44:14,320 --> 01:44:16,723 [scoffs] You really believe that? 1998 01:44:22,328 --> 01:44:24,631 If you keep going with this, 1999 01:44:24,764 --> 01:44:26,900 the press will eat you alive. 2000 01:44:27,330 --> 01:44:28,968 Okay? This case will follow you forever. 2001 01:44:29,102 --> 01:44:30,336 In the meantime, 2002 01:44:30,503 --> 01:44:32,639 some politician will take your job, 2003 01:44:32,772 --> 01:44:34,741 a criminal goes back on the street, 2004 01:44:34,874 --> 01:44:37,430 and a good man and his family will be... 2005 01:44:38,511 --> 01:44:39,879 just destroyed. 2006 01:44:43,160 --> 01:44:45,218 Where is the justice in that? 2007 01:45:05,372 --> 01:45:07,407 [melancholy music playing] 2008 01:45:19,850 --> 01:45:20,120 Amen. 2009 01:45:38,238 --> 01:45:39,739 Looks like the storm passed. 2010 01:45:40,674 --> 01:45:42,442 Yeah. I think so. 2011 01:45:49,249 --> 01:45:50,617 [engine starts] 2012 01:46:06,666 --> 01:46:08,802 [Eric] Hello? Where's our new DA? 2013 01:46:10,270 --> 01:46:12,305 - Hey. - Hey. 2014 01:46:12,472 --> 01:46:14,307 - For the new digs. - Oh. [chuckles] 2015 01:46:14,474 --> 01:46:16,643 - Thanks. - Yeah. It's real. 2016 01:46:16,776 --> 01:46:18,645 Easy plant to take care of. 2017 01:46:20,246 --> 01:46:22,982 - It really thrives on neglect. - [chuckles] 2018 01:46:23,116 --> 01:46:25,185 - You did it. - [sighs] 2019 01:46:26,920 --> 01:46:28,288 I hope it was worth it. 2020 01:46:33,159 --> 01:46:34,127 [knocks on table] 2021 01:46:34,260 --> 01:46:35,862 Ale House later. 2022 01:46:35,995 --> 01:46:36,963 You're buying. 2023 01:47:00,200 --> 01:47:02,188 Kung fu! 2024 01:47:02,322 --> 01:47:05,358 - Hi. - And the 4Runner is officially sold. 2025 01:47:05,492 --> 01:47:06,326 Okay. 2026 01:47:08,280 --> 01:47:09,290 [sighs] 2027 01:47:09,896 --> 01:47:10,864 Come here. 2028 01:47:14,634 --> 01:47:16,102 [baby cooing] 2029 01:47:16,236 --> 01:47:17,203 [both gasp] 2030 01:47:17,337 --> 01:47:18,338 - Hi. - Oh. 2031 01:47:20,600 --> 01:47:21,408 Good morning. Dada. 2032 01:47:21,541 --> 01:47:22,842 [Justin and Allison] Yeah. 2033 01:47:22,976 --> 01:47:24,844 - There she goes. - Come here. Here we go. 2034 01:47:24,978 --> 01:47:27,947 Yeah. Yeah. You're doing good. Hi. 2035 01:47:28,810 --> 01:47:30,984 [sighs] It sucks. I think she has my eyes. 2036 01:47:31,151 --> 01:47:32,318 - Really? - Yeah. 2037 01:47:32,452 --> 01:47:34,320 - No. - Yeah. 2038 01:47:34,454 --> 01:47:35,922 - You have beautiful eyes. - Well... 2039 01:47:36,990 --> 01:47:38,425 Look, I think, maybe mine. 2040 01:47:38,558 --> 01:47:39,759 They're changing a little bit. 2041 01:47:39,893 --> 01:47:42,495 - [baby cooing] - Yeah, hi. 2042 01:47:42,629 --> 01:47:44,431 - She has my mouth. - I hope not. 2043 01:47:44,564 --> 01:47:46,366 [both laugh] 2044 01:47:47,701 --> 01:47:48,935 Definitely your elbows, though. 2045 01:47:49,690 --> 01:47:50,236 My elb-- [laughs] 2046 01:47:50,370 --> 01:47:52,500 My elbow. [gasps] 2047 01:47:52,138 --> 01:47:54,207 Look at your beautiful elbows. You're blessed. 2048 01:47:54,341 --> 01:47:56,276 - [laughs] - My greatest feature. 2049 01:47:59,746 --> 01:48:00,747 Hi. 2050 01:48:02,882 --> 01:48:04,840 My girls. 2051 01:48:04,217 --> 01:48:06,653 My girls with beautiful elbows. Yeah. 2052 01:48:06,786 --> 01:48:08,621 - [knock at door] - Oh. 2053 01:48:09,255 --> 01:48:10,557 Oh. 2054 01:48:10,724 --> 01:48:12,425 Who could that be at a time like this? 2055 01:48:12,592 --> 01:48:13,793 - Hey, peanut. - There we go. 2056 01:48:13,927 --> 01:48:15,128 Hi, honey. 2057 01:48:15,795 --> 01:48:17,130 Okay. 2058 01:48:36,583 --> 01:48:38,585 [somber music playing]